• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Aizen goes to court

Kazuma_kuwabara said:
Edit: But then how that system will act about Aizen's crimes when is like punishing a London guy in Paris for doing bad things in Spain, what the **** happens with that irl?
Click to expand...
if i'm not mistaken, the person can face justice in either country or both if the diplomacy department agree in doing so

For example, there was a brazillian soccer player who was accused of r*** in Spain, he faced trial in Spain but brazillian justice asked for him to be deported back to Brazil and face trial here, where he got condemned too.

Since it would involve diplomacy and Soul Society is never ever accepting Aizen to face human justice, the trial'd have to be in Soul Society and abide by its penal code. OP should declare how familiar Higuruma is with Soul Society's legal system
 
It doesn’t matter if they accept it or not, Higuruma would force his techniques rule onto the trial.

Common sense already tells us the technique works on Cursed Spirits who are far from being human or needing to face legal justice.
 
I went back to Higuruma vs Yuji and its stated he killed countless cursed spirits, if the domain rules applies to beings such as them then I think we all can agree it would also apply to Aizen.
 
ShionAH said:
I went back to Higuruma vs Yuji and its stated he killed countless cursed spirits, if the domain rules applies to beings such as them then I think we all can agree it would also apply to Aizen.
Click to expand...
It should be directly stated that they have to abide by japanese penal code and strictly that

Also, wouldn't it be IC for Higuruma to abide by the laws of another place if he is part of the trial in this place? He's super into morality, justice, doing the right think, etc iirc, so he would want to abide by SS' laws, no?
 
Nonynho said:
It should be directly stated that they have to abide by japanese penal code and strictly that
Click to expand...
Thats kinda his whole domain, if cursed spirits who are FAR from human can be trialed then Aizen would also be.
 
ShionAH said:
Thats kinda his whole domain, if cursed spirits who are FAR from human can be trialed then Aizen would also be.
Click to expand...
His domain is forcing creatures to be trialed, it is not forcing them to be trialed under japanese law, those are two very different things and the second one would need proof
 
Nonynho said:
it is not forcing them to be trialed under japanese law
Click to expand...
Where did you get this?? Ofc it does, do you think the domain is basically useless to anyone thats not a Japanese citizen or something when we already know it works on Cursed Spirits?
 
Rogue_Forge said:
hiromi-higuruma-and-judgeman-from-jujutsu-kaisen-v0-vadrkvo3jl9d1.png
Click to expand...
Higuruma when he fights Yujiro:
 
ShionAH said:
Where did you get this?? Ofc it does, do you think the domain is basically useless to anyone thats not a Japanese citizen or something when we already know it works on Cursed Spirits?
Click to expand...
forcing to be trialed =/= forcing to be trialed under japanese law

that would be totally ooc because it can act against his justice and moralism principles
specially in this case where the guy is not being trialed in Japan
For you to say that the domain enforces specifically japanese law and no other under any circumstance, it should be specifically stated
 
Let me say this, if you find me a single scene or statement from the manga that implies the domains entire theme and system changes depending on the target then I'll concede. Until then we'll go off by what we see and whats stated which is that Higuruma's domain forces his target into a Japanese Legal System and puts them under trial.

You kinda have to prove the entire domain would change for Aizen when its also completely against the whole theme of non lethal domains being super unfair to the opponent
 
"i'm obsessed that people are trialed under fair and square rules so lemme enforce japanese laws in a interdimensional place that is not japan to prosecute this guy"
 
Hakari is obsessed with gambling.

Guess just how annoyingly unfair his domain feels like for his opponents? Non lethal are ALWAYS biased for their users lol
 
ShionAH said:
Let me say this, if you find me a single scene or statement from the manga that implies the domains entire theme and system changes depending on the target then I'll concede
Click to expand...
lemme change this to what i actually mean so that it makes sense

Let me say this, if you find me a single scene or statement from the manga that implies the domains entire theme and system changes depending on the place* then I'll concede
Click to expand...
To that i say:

It wouldn't be in-character of him to enfore japanese law in a place that is not Japan
Because it is not fair
And he likes things to be fair
So OP can just change to say Higuruma knows SS' law or got prep time to study it
 
ShionAH said:
Guess just how annoyingly unfair his domain feels like for his opponents? Non lethal are ALWAYS biased for their users lol
Click to expand...
Higuruma is obsessed with fairness, he'd like it to be fair for Aizen because that is his bias
 
Something cool to comment: as Higuruma was a defense attorney, wouldn't it be also nice af to see him defending?
 
It wouldn't be in character for both Higuruma and Jujutsu itself to force an extremely unfair disadvantage the USER OF A DOMAIN without them gaining anything back, Higuruma being forced to learn a WHOLE new legal system he has NO information on is an extremely absurd claim you'd have to prove
Higuruma is obsessed with fairness, he'd like it to be fair for Aizen because that is his bias
Click to expand...
He'd also want to like... you know actually be able to do a trial with Aizen. Lol.
Something cool to comment: as Higuruma was a defense attorney, wouldn't it be also nice af to see him defending?
Click to expand...
I felt like Higuruma's entire character shifted after his Awakening, he goes from a nice humble guy and a defense attorney to a pretty messed up prosecutor who "likes" murder. That's why he "goes back to his roots" after fighting Yuji and returns as a good guy
 
ShionAH said:
It wouldn't be in character for both Higuruma and Jujutsu itself to force an extremely unfair disadvantage the USER OF A DOMAIN without them gaining anything back, Higuruma being forced to learn a WHOLE new legal system he has NO information on is an extremely absurd claim you'd have to prove
Click to expand...
Since it'd be HIS preference to trial him in the most fair of circustances we can

a) Change the location to somewhere in Japan so that he can abide by this country's penal code
b) Give him time to study SS' penal code or just state that he dominates it, since he wouldn't like to enforce Japan's penal code under anywhere that is not Japan because that is his personality trait, to like fair things and dislike unfair things
c) Get a scan with him enforcing japanese law outside of Japan despite this being unfair and then someone would be able to give this line of thought the middle finger and proceed exactly as things are despite now literally needing just the smallest of the tweaks for it to work
 
All that yap when I alr know Higuruma would instantly learn all about the laws of the Soul Society just by listening to Aizen talk for a few seconds because the Narrator would glaze him with "The Genius" talk while even Aizen looks at him with shock 😭 🙏 🔥
 
Doesn't Aizen neg diff this scenario by just being worlds apart more intelligent than his opponent, and can manipulate him easily?

He doesnt even need to know the law of japan intimately. He can know everything about his enemy just by looking at him
 
Read 12 here, and This article and this one right here.

If he were to enforce Japan's penal code outside of Japan without diplomacy and international he'd be commiting a crime in the eyes of international law.
Now you tell me who is not wanting to commit a crime for no reason?
Now also tell me who is the part that won't be using diplomacy with the human world?
 
ShionAH said:
All that yap when I alr know Higuruma would instantly learn all about the laws of the Soul Society just by listening to Aizen talk for a few seconds because the Narrator would glaze him with "The Genius" talk while even Aizen looks at him with shock 😭 🙏 🔥
Click to expand...
Arcker123 said:
Doesn't Aizen neg diff this scenario by just being worlds apart more intelligent than his opponent, and can manipulate him easily?

He doesnt even need to know the law of japan intimately. He can know everything about his enemy just by looking at him
Click to expand...
First we talk about OP being actually IC for Higuruma

Then his ass gets no-diffed lmfao
 
Nonynho said:
Read 12 here, and This article and this one right here.

If he were to enforce Japan's penal code outside of Japan without diplomacy and international he'd be commiting a crime in the eyes of international law.
Now you tell me who is not wanting to commit a crime for no reason?
Now also tell me who is the part that won't be using diplomacy with the human world?
Click to expand...
Aizen has committed mass murder on japanese soil tbf

Aizen also resists every ability of the judge even if he were found guilty so
 
ShionAH said:
Cursed Spirits would fall under this and yet Higuruma clearly has no problems fighting them.
Click to expand...
Arcker123 said:
Aizen has committed mass murder on japanese soil tbf
Click to expand...
I was speaking about the Soul Society because it needs to negotiate with the human world to apply international law and it won't...
as both i said before and i implied heavily...
 
I don't see your point. Higuruma's technique isn't so weak that being from a different place completely nullifies it lets be fr, this is implied many times in the series and especially the fact that we have never seen such limitation for "fairness" (when it wouldn't be fair for Higuruma meaning it isn't even fair)

But whatevers 🤷‍♂️
 
Its not enforcing state law internationally to try a foreign national for crimes they committed in that aforementioned state
Hagane_no_Saiyajin said:
Just better to say that either Aizen get executed or Kanzen Saimin is confiscated
Click to expand...
The problem is that the ability can't do either.

Aizen resists conceptual sealing and power null; and the Hogyoku will resurrect him
 
Nonynho said:
OP should declare how familiar Higuruma is with Soul Society's legal system
Click to expand...
Honestly, I was assuming SBA with Higurama, but should it be labeled as a weakness that Deadly Sentencing only applies the modern Japanese legal system?
 
Honestly, if this match takes place in an equalized Japan, I can't see why Aizen can't be tried for the massacre of japanese citizens he went on in Deicide

@Nonynho I assumed this took place in Japan
 
Hagane_no_Saiyajin said:
Honestly, I was assuming SBA with Higurama, but should it be labeled as a weakness that Deadly Sentencing only applies the modern Japanese legal system?
Click to expand...
yup
but for simplicity sake just say in OP that he knows SS' legal system, pretty please?
 
Arcker123 said:
Honestly, if this match takes place in an equalized Japan, I can't see why Aizen can't be tried for the massacre of japanese citizens he went on in Deicide

@Nonynho I assumed this took place in Japan
Click to expand...
if it was i'd be basically dead silent ngl
 
Central 46/Soul.Society law legal proceedings are show trials where you can get consecutive life sentences for just speaking, so ig the JJK guy stomps given the utter lack of evidence you'd need to convince a SS court.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Hagane_no_Saiyajin
Rohan goes to court
2
Replies
42
Views
3K
Hagane_no_Saiyajin
Hagane_no_Saiyajin
Nonynho
  • Locked
GRACE [7-0-0] Literally better call Saul - Higuruma vs MCU's She-Hulk
Replies
17
Views
2K
Nonynho
Nonynho
Tots_Real
A Court Case: Hiromi Higuruma vs She-Hulk
Replies
4
Views
2K
That_moron2
That_moron2
Back
Top