• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Akame Ga Kill High 6-B rating should be removed.

Status
Not open for further replies.
The walls are huge, they dwarf the buildings as well.

Recall the walls surround a 200,000 square kilometer city.

Also, you don't give any good reasonings to the calc being wrong. Your claim of the calc making the walls and buildings big isn't an issue because the calc pixel scales the size of the dust cloud that is behind the walls. And with context we know it's far behind the walls given the crater the dust cloud is over is larger than mountains.
 
I think what IMade is saying is that you are focusing way too much on houses that are most likely merely the victim of a poor attempt at scaling things up. But we see the relation between the dust cloud and the dust cloud to the wall, which is what really matters.
 
A victim of a poor attempt of scaling things up?

Narutoverse recently got almost verswide revision for this "poor attempts".Every detail and method of scaling is questioned,just go and look at the calcs,we desperately try to find a new method and object to scale things,and in this calc we don't even see how he found the crater diameter.I donl't think we should go easy on this.

Recall the walls surround a 200,000 square kilometer city.

Would be good to have a scan.This is size is too much for just a city.

And with context we know it's far behind the walls given the crater the dust cloud is over is larger than mountains.

It isn't far.

We use 609 meters for standard mountain size for calcs in here.

Also I never got why we scaled this to every characters AP and Dura,no one tanked that attack so far,but anyway,this isn't the point here.

I'll ask calc group members to comment here.
 
Honestly a better argument would be that it should be removed due to being an outlier and the calc assumes vaporization despite there being chunks of rocks within the dust.
 
The outlier argument would be a pretty poor argument though, far from a good one. This is an attack from one of the God tiers of the verse to which barely anyone really scales to (especially since this series has a slightly big cast).

Also, "The Empire is a superpower that has lasted for over 1000 years, boasting vast territories and resources. Its capital city is enormous, covering roughly 200,000 sq. kilometers, and is encircled on all sides by a huge wall. The capital's various districts are separated by large canals in which trade ships run through.".

Yes, it is ridiculously big. Does that matter...? Considering this is an empire that made high end technological bio weapons from legendary monsters, not really. Between the wall itself, which we see close up and we know wraps around the entire main city of the empire and some buildings, I really don't see why the buildings take precedence.

Not to mention steam is both drawn like this in the manga, as Therefir points out after also commenting it seems more like dust but then correcting himself, and what we see are incredibly small bits of rock. Previous attacks from the armor also vaporized stuff.
 
Unknown2mrk
And the distcance from the PoV to the dust cloud being 252.281 kilometers comes from? I don't see any explication or reason whatsoever for this distance.
 
AlexSoloVaAlFuturo said:
Unknown2mrk
And the distcance from the PoV to the dust cloud being 252.281 kilometers comes from? I don't see any explication or reason whatsoever for this distance.
Click to expand...
This is because the city has a stated area of 200,000 square kilometers and is shaped as a circle.

That gives a radius of 252 kilometers.
 
And the assumption of the cloud being the same size as the craters comes from? Mushroom clouds change overtime, so saying that the red line has the same size as the crater is like throwing an arrow to the unknown.
 
My suggestion for the better calc is to find the size of the wall and scale it to the crater and not just throw ridiculously high numbers that don't match the visuals.
 
You can't scale the crater to the wall though? Do you know that? They're never shown together on the same panel nor anything of reference.

There is only 1 shot of the explosion and 1 of the crater. The walls are not visible in any of them.
 
AlexSoloVaAlFuturo said:
And the assumption of the cloud being the same size as the craters comes from? Mushroom clouds change overtime, so saying that the red line has the same size as the crater is like throwing an arrow to the unknown.
Click to expand...
That is what Liger and VersusJunkie deemed suitable.
 
I can't post pics,check the calculation page,there is a pic where we see the wall and the crater in one shot.

We will have to find a new method anyway.As I said these numbers don't match what we see,everything here suggests that the crater is small and not 89km in diameter or even slightly close to that.
 
IMadeThisOn8-1-2017 said:
That is what Liger and VersusJunkie deemed suitable.
Click to expand...
Does this thing has an actual fire ball? Because if it doesn't have it then it isn't usable, depending of the way that the ground was detroyed the cloud that can came from it can be two, three, or whoever knows times bigger than the crater itself as actual mushroom clouds are hot gas + air + other stuff. Not to mention if it the panel used is certain amount of time after the cloud would expand even bigger of what I said before.
 
Dzhindzholia said:
I can't post pics,check the calculation page,there is a pic where we see the wall and the crater in one shot.
We will have to find a new method anyway.As I said these numbers don't match what we see,everything here suggests that the crater is small and not 89km in diameter or even slightly close to that.
Click to expand...
You're thinking of the wrong crater, dude. There are two craters. One from the laser and the other from the energy ball.
 
AlexSoloVaAlFuturo said:
IMadeThisOn8-1-2017 said:
That is what Liger and VersusJunkie deemed suitable.
Click to expand...
Does this thing has an actual fire ball? Because if it doesn't have it then it isn't usable, depending of the way that the ground was detroyed the cloud that can came from it can be two, three, or whoever knows times bigger than the crater itself as actual mushroom clouds are hot gas + air + other stuff. Not to mention if it the panel used is certain amount of time after the cloud would expand even bigger of what I said before.
Click to expand...
The panel is used is right after the panel of the mushroom cloud being made on panel.

It's not know what it is, however it was deemed to be vaporization by Therefir, VS, Schnee and Liger for following vaporization standards.
 
I contacted Ugarik a while ago to evaluate as well.

Anyway, Im going to sit here and watch, can't really argue calcs
 
IMadeThisOn8-1-2017 said:
The panel is used is right after the panel of the mushroom cloud being made on panel.
It's not know what it is, however it was deemed to be vaporization by Therefir, VS, Schnee and Liger for following vaporization standards.
Click to expand...
I see, still it is very iffy to assume that that red line there is equal to the crater when this one isn't even the smallest part of the cloud itself now is known how much it expanded.

If we have a way to calc the crater itself, it will be much safer, as an explosion/dust cloud may or may not have the same size, being either smaller or bigger, as the final crater.
 
High 7-A with pulverization, so if it follows the vap stuff then needs to be changed. And the pixelscaling picture is dEd, so I don't know if it is accurated or not.
 
I believe the crater using pulverization is High 7-A because of using the nearby mountains for a size. However, the horizon view of the mushroom cloud is what makes it 6-B because the horizon view has a distance of 252 km given the Capital is a circle that has an area of 200,000 square kilometers.

Here is the statement for the size.
 
Doesn't the calc in the OP use the old version of angsizing?
 
I don't think the city is 200k km^2.It just doesn't fit and doesn't make sense at all.I don't agree with these ridiculous numbers.
 
Dzhindzholia said:
I don't think the city is 200k km^2.It just doesn't fit and doesn't make sense at all.I don't agree with these ridiculous numbers.
Click to expand...
This isn't an argument, it's you stating your opinion.

Anyways, it makes perfect semse it's huge given that the Capital also has a canal that goes for 2000 kilometers. You forget how huge the author has made things in Akame Ga Kill.

Did you remember that Night Raid's second hide out was over 800 kilometers from the Capital? That the church was over 500 kilometers from the Capital?
 
I don't agree with the explosion being 89km in diameter.

After looking at the feat I just can't imagine it to be that big.Using average mountain size is the best option here.But anyway,all images are presented on the calc page,The calc is wrong in one way or another,it should either be removed or recalculated.
 
The Stated size is just the author going into constant length on how huge the Empire Actually is, in fact there are even statements saying it can cover the entire continent but we don't use those.
 
Again, this is an empire that has existed for 1000 years and around the time of its first King, used advanced technology to create bio weapons from the flesh and blood of almost fantastical beasts in their world.

A really massive city, which you can even see is goddamn massive in the anime and manga, is far from the most disbelievable thing.
 
Either way, the calc is outdated as it's using the old form of Angsizing.

So we need to figure out if the rest is correct, and then recalc it.
 
This is an stated distance, and stated things will always take priority above anything we will calc no matter how mrk is the drawer.

Aside of that, using that red line of the dust cloud is a nei, nothing that has been said here suggest that it has the same size, or similar, as the crater itself to use it, the red line isn't even the smallest part of the cloud. It is like throwing an arrow to the sky hopping that you will hit the right answer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

V999
Akame VS Gildarts (0-0-0)
Replies
6
Views
505
V999
V999
V999
Wave VS Humungousaur (1-6-0)
2
Replies
47
Views
3K
zaraus
zaraus
  • Locked
Vs Battles Terms
Replies
19
Views
1K
DarkGrath
DarkGrath
SatellaTheWoE
Akame vs Reid Astrea 7-1-0
2
Replies
49
Views
3K
SatellaTheWoE
SatellaTheWoE
RandomGuy2345
Johnny Test vs Akame (cause me bored)
2
Replies
67
Views
3K
RandomGuy2345
RandomGuy2345
Back
Top