- 4,203
- 2,783
Not online apparently.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Sonic game canonicity and statements on Classic Sonic's AP
- Thread starter OculoOmnibus
- Start date
- 4,203
- 2,783
Even if its not its common misinfo that Ian could have seen. That doesn't really make him unreliable imo.
- 12,128
- 4,366
Then how do you know that it is even a thing?
- 4,203
- 2,783
Follow up messages.
- 5,256
- 3,409
You know, this is Q&A.
If you guys have a problem with that.
Do a crt, because I think the OP's question has already been answered, although he disagrees with the reasoning.
If you guys have a problem with that.
Do a crt, because I think the OP's question has already been answered, although he disagrees with the reasoning.
- 190
- 54
- Thread starter
- #46
Yeah I agree, the PA statements should be a CRT now.
- 4,203
- 2,783
- 12,128
- 4,366
Wait, this is QnA? Damn, second time this happened when i confused with crt
- 5,256
- 3,409
If you're talking about my message. I'm not a fan of Sonic games.
It would only be more productive for you to talk about this in a crt, because this is a question and answer. All this discussion would lead nowhere.
- 5,256
- 3,409
- 190
- 54
Gilad_Hyperstar
He/Him- 11,411
- 4,333
Gemerl, Metal Sonic, Mecha Sonic? Final Weapon? The list goes on
- 4,203
- 2,783
All made for the Chaos Emeralds.
- 12,128
- 4,366
Proof of this? FW, Mecha and metal specially
- 4,203
- 2,783
Eggman's entire scheme in S3&K was revolving around the (unknown from)M.E
See above. Also Mecha doesn't shoot the energy balls in base form, so why was the hole there?
Shadow's biodata
- 12,128
- 4,366
so? eggman didn't had a hold on it to study to do that until the very 2 final stages
not enough information on that to draw any conclusive argument
he didn't had it for the majority of the entire timeline dude
Gilad_Hyperstar
He/Him- 11,411
- 4,333
Metal Sonic was never made with the chaos emeralds in mind. Hell, Sonic CD doesn't have them at all
Metal was designed by Eggman to match Sonic, and for Mecha it's even more reaching
Gilad_Hyperstar
He/Him- 11,411
- 4,333
Not disagreeing with you, but even if he had, it was Neo Metal Sonic who had this data, a form Metal Sonic self upgraded himself into to surpass Sonic
- 4,203
- 2,783
He's been able to jury rig machines before(Sonic Mania), given the time between Sky Sanctuary and Doomsday I don't think that its unrealistic to think that he could have modified it.
He did when he used the Chaos Emeralds.
- 305
- 326
And? Eggman didn't have the master emerald until the very end and even then, it wasn't even used on Mecha. His entire scheme was to steal the ME and...seems like we know for what machine he stole it for. It was instead used for a vastly different machine. I don't remember the Knuckles story, but I don't recall Eggman doing much of anything there in regards to Mecha. Mecha just...kinda started using the master emerald as a temporary amp.
Metal was not, at all, designed with the Chaos Emerald in mind. The Chaos Emeralds weren't even the gems Eggman was hunting when he built Metal Sonic. We have zero reason to assume Eggman built Metal Sonic with the idea of harnessing the Chaos Emeralds when we know Metal was built...specifically to match Sonic in speed.
Even using the Shadow data. That didn't play a role until heroes and it was in his Neo Metal Form. A form Metal (I think) created himself without Eggman's involvement.
These two have, at worst, no evidence, and at best, miniscule evidence to suggest they were created with the Emeralds in mind. Or, more accurately, specifically created with some arbitrary design that makes THEM specifically able to use them.
- 12,128
- 4,366
- 4,203
- 2,783
The fact that his whole plan in S3&K was based on the Master Emerald?
Metal didn't have a Chaos Emerald iirc.
- 12,128
- 4,366
you mean the gem eggman has not even get close to study, or had the poccession of, until the very last stage? mecha specially couldn't, since when he was made eggman didn't had the emerald and couldn't have upgraded him in any way, since he was abandoned after his failure against sonic, his plan was not "based" on the master emerald, his plan was to get the emerald, you are reaching right now
- 4,203
- 2,783
Master Emerald Energy = Chaos Energy. Its not a stretch to say that Eggman can make his robots harness Chaos Energy.
Gilad_Hyperstar
He/Him- 11,411
- 4,333
Still doesn't mean Eggman designed these robots with the emeralds in mind, especially Metal Sonic since the emeralds aren't even in CD
- 12,128
- 4,366
unless you have any evidence at all that he did that in the first place
- 4,203
- 2,783
Research Chaos Energy? Are you fr?
What I do like is that you've gone after an insignificant point in my argument, and one that doesn't heavily impact the topic.
- 12,128
- 4,366
Non sequitur, researching chaos energy , which he couldn't have done at that time since he never had the emeralds with him for long enough to do thar, means nothing without you proving the base of your point, that having something built arround it is must
You are but talking a theory without showing any proof for the root of everything you just said
- 4,203
- 2,783
You don't need to have things to research them. Just touching a Chaos Emerald doesn't give you power. Why did the Deadly Six use the power harnesses? Why can't every ************ use Chaos Control?
- 12,128
- 4,366
If you want to analise them you do
says this why?
they did use, what ia your point?
Because that is a more sophisticated aplication of chaos energy? This is like asking why doesn't every ki user use the kaioken
- 4,203
- 2,783
I'm saying this because you can't use Chaos Energy by just touching a Chaos Emerald, and thus robots can not use Chaos Energy unless they are made to be able to use it. Not for it but to be able to do so like a bonus.
- 12,128
- 4,366
see, this is the thing you need to prove for anything you are saying to have any short of basis, also silver sonic, mecha sonic, metal sonic, shadow, emerl and gemerl all disagree with you
you didn't proved or presented any proof for this tho, you drawing this conclusion from nothing
- 4,203
- 2,783
1. No normal character is shown being powered up by just touching the emerald.
2. The Deadly Six used special devices instead of just holding them
3. Machines like the eclipse cannon use special ports instead of leaving them on the ground
4. The ancients used special machines to power up the Titians with a Chaos Emerald, not just having them eat it.
- 12,128
- 4,366
mecha sonic, gemerl, silver sonic and metal sonic
yeah, because they were using a special aplication of them to amplify their own machine control, this really proves nothing
i am sorry, what is this supposed to prove? the eclipse canon had them in their core to use their power, again, not sure what you are trying to prove here
yeah, so that they didn't need to have them in hand every time, like how they do in frontiers, honestly also proves nothing since they wanted to get the emeralds to the master emerald in case of failure, so of course they wouldn't install the emeralds into them, that would defeat the whole purpose of what they wanted to do
- 4,203
- 2,783
Gmerl can copy for one thing, and was based on Emerl who is tied to the Chaos Emeralds, not sure why he is part of the convo. Silver Sonic was not powered by a Chaos Emerald merely holding one, and if he was which you have implied you believe then that would not be possible if he wasn't made for that. Metal has only used the Chaos Emeralds as Neo who copies Shadow's biodata(i.e Chaos Powers). This leaves mecha as an outlier in the fold who likely would have been built to be able to use Chaos Energy.
Proof of this?
If you just having one powers you up then this would not be needed.
Leaving them in the cockpit would work, and be more effective since it is concealed inside the shell. I don't understand what you are trying to say in the second part.
- 12,128
- 4,366
"based" as in "not entirely equal, just based on" therefore to say that he still has the same connection seens baseless
please prove this, you keep saying that he needs to be built for that when you have provide no proof for such
sonic rivals says hi
what outlier? you haven't shown evidence of any pattern for an outlier to exist, you haven't even proven that mecha was built to harness chaos energy
the literal entire plot point of the emeralds for them was to control the zombots....
the eclipse canon is there, the emeralds were put on it, so it was powered by them, excuse me but what is your point again?
it wouldn't really, it is as safe as powering them up with the emeralds and them sending them, having the emeralds inside of them does nothing more than make them have the possibility to lose said emerald later, plus how they wouldn't be able to share the emeralds evenly between the 4 of them, it is is just not necessary
the whole point is that they wanted to bring the emeralds to the master emeralds in case the titans failed, having the emeralds in them defeats the purpose
- 5,256
- 3,409
Are you still here? Here is questions and answers.
- 12,128
- 4,366
.....why do i keep forgeting that? LoL
- 4,203
- 2,783
This conversation has completely veered away from the point of this not even crt, and I'm losing my sanity. I'm calling this quits.
Similar threads
