One Piece: Thriller Bark Size Change

[Kachon123]

Revising Thriller Bark's size.

This new calc for Thriller Bark has been accepted

One Piece: Thriller Bark

vsbattles.fandom.com

The old calc should be replaced with the one above for a couple of reasons:

1. Uses angsizing instead of pixel scaling, unlike the new one
   
   • Pixel scaling calcs take precedent over angsizing calcs
2. Unrealistic results
   
   • The old calc claims that Thriller Bark has a diameter of only about 1680 meters. We know that this can't be true. Thriller Bark is the world's largest ship, making it much bigger than supermassive ships like the Queen Mama Chanter, which dwarfs 60 meter tall ships like the Thousand Sunny. Thriller Bark is a whole island noted to be so big that nobody has been able to determine its size. This is important because several other islands contain landmarks with sizes much beyond 1.6 km. On top of that, it took Luffy's group unquantifiably more than 20 minutes on foot to walk only partway through the forest. 1.4 m/s * 1200 s = 1680 meters. Unless I missed something, they did not walk the entirety of the island's length during those 20 minutes.

 

[KingTempest]

Damn

 

[SlendVeny]

Sick, I agree.

 

[Ryuga21]

Following

 

[Damage3245]

Addressing the second part of the OP first.

Thriller Bark is a whole island noted to be so big that nobody has been able to determine its size. This is important because several other islands contain landmarks with sizes much beyond 1.6 km.

The reason given for why nobody can grasp its size there is because it is its full dimensions are shrouded in mist. Not because it so unfathomably huge.

The old calc claims that Thriller Bark has a diameter of only about 1680 meters. We know that this can't be true. Thriller Bark is the world's largest ship, making it much bigger than supermassive ships like the Queen Mama Chanter, which dwarfs 60 meter tall ships like the Thousand Sunny.

The Queen Mama Chanter doesn't have an official size figure I believe, but even if we deduce its size by comparing it to the Sunny I don't think we have any confirmation that Big Mom's ship is over 1680 meters in size.

Also, the currently used calc of mine in the OP that you've linked to only has 1680 meters for the land inside Thriller Bark. Thriller Bark as a whole ship is 1953 meters across.

---

And now addressing the first part of the OP:

Uses angsizing instead of pixel scaling, unlike the new one

• Pixel scaling calcs take precedent over angsizing calcs

The calculation linked in the OP for the current size of Thriller Bark does not use Angsizing in Method 1. Just pixelscaling.

 

[That_moron2]

Neutral for now, leaning disagree

 

[SlendVeny]

The Queen Mama Chanter doesn't have an official size figure I believe, but even if we deduce its size by comparing it to the Sunny I don't think we have any confirmation that Big Mom's ship is over 1680 meters in size.

If you use that image, I'm pretty sure it's nearly 10x the size of the Sunny.

 

[Damage3245]

If you use that image, I'm pretty sure it's nearly 10x the size of the Sunny.

The Thousand Sunny is 39 meters long. Even if the Queen Mama Chanter was thirty times longer than the Thousand Sunny, it'd only be 1170 meters long and smaller than Thriller Bark.

 

[MonkeyOfLife]

The Thousand Sunny is 39 meters long. Even if the Queen Mama Chanter was thirty times longer than the Thousand Sunny, it'd only be 1170 meters long and smaller than Thriller Bark.

Yee but it seems to be much bigger than that

Thousand Sunny length = 105px (39m)

Tarteship width = 136px (50.514285714286m)

Tarteship width = 32.7px (50.514285714286m)

Germa66 Castle top height = 478px (738.40454346877m)

Germa66 Castle top height = 29px (738.40454346877m)

BigMom Ship length = 107px (2724.4581431434m)

Would also be somewhat consistent

 

[Damage3245]

I'll just note for now that Thriller Bark's title is the world's largest pirate ship, which doesn't necessarily mean the longest. I wouldn't say the Queen Mama Chanter being pixelscaling to be 2724 meters long (assuming the pixelscaling is correct) is an automatic debunk of the existing calc. Especially since we don't know how long the Queen Mama Chanter has been around or if the old man who made the original statement of Thriller Bark is aware of it.

EDIT: I've also found some panels that suggest the Queen Mama Chanter may not be as large as that.

 

[MonkeyOfLife]

Especially since we don't know how long the Queen Mama Chanter has been around or if the old man who made the original statement of Thriller Bark is aware of it.

The statement isn't only from the old man

12
死んで骨だけブルック登場! 世界一の巨大船で大暴れ!!

ゴースト島と呼ばれる、スリラーバークに上陸 した一味!!奪われた影を取り戻す為、七武海の 一人、ゲッコー・モリアとバトルを繰り広げた。

12
Brook appears dead with only bones! Rampage on the world's biggest ship!

The crew landed on Thriller Bark, a.k.a. Ghost Island! In order to recover their stolen shadows, they battle with Gekko Moriah, one of the Shichibukai.

I'll just note for now that Thriller Bark's title is the world's largest pirate ship, which doesn't necessarily mean the longest.

That would make no sense especially when ships are scaled based on length and height, both of which big mom ship would be bigger in

I wouldn't say the Queen Mama Chanter being pixelscaling to be 2724 meters long (assuming the pixelscaling is correct) is an automatic debunk of the existing calc.

My "debunk" was only for your statement saying that the big mom ship being only 1170 meters long even tho it can be scaled way higher

 

[Damage3245]

My "debunk" was only for your statement saying that the big mom ship being only 1170 meters long even tho it can be scaled way higher

Fair enough, I was only making a vague estimate there in response to the "10x the size of the Sunny" comment.

 

[SlendVeny]

Fair enough, I was only making a vague estimate there in response to the "10x the size of the Sunny" comment.

For some reason, I forgot how much 10 was.