didnt Shanks could keep Kaido away during Marineford? if yes, Mihawk should scale above him
We know nothing of what happened during that encounter, we can't use it to scale.
currently his justification is "Comparable to the other Yonko, such as Shanks" based off the fact he is a Yonko, nothing says he should be comparable to the other Yonko in his base form. So that justification already accounts for Kaido's zoan forms.
Kaido can fight big mom in base and she has the same justification. So the zoan forms should be amps on top of that.
She doesn't have the same justification on her profile.
Oops my bad, why doesn't she though? Eh but her speed is still scaled to whitebeard's, and they both scale to the same value in AP, so kaido should still scale to the yonko in base.
No, they're being scaled to that value in the first place via the fact they hold Yonko titles and they're peers with Whitebeard and Shanks, that comparability should be treated as them at their strongest and not weakest otherwise they're not comparable like the profiles state.
Well big mom scales to the yonko, but kaido can fight her equally without using his zoan. That clearly means kaido gets stronger.
She scales to Whitebeard in speed not AP & Durability and speed is equalized so no.
Well fine, whatever. Mihawk has the AP advantage normally but kaido evens it with conqurors haki, kaido's durability is even greater since I think he can't even hurt himself, so that might also give him the durability advantage. So now kaido doesn't have the stat advantage anymore but he should have better durability. I'm still voting kaido for the other reasons.
So far Kaido has only shown some basic presence sensing while Mihawk scales to or above Zoro, so there's a decent advantage in Mihawk's favor.
I'm not sure it's been accepted that Zoans increase speed ratings on the site.
I think I brought it up in another thread but Zoro (a mini version of Mihawk) dealt with nearly all of Kaido's versatility, although Zoro has foxfire style and Mihawk has yet to be confirmed to have that so boro breathe is still viable. Zoro bypassed his regeneration leaving a permanent scar so it shouldn't be a problem for Mihawk. His electricity manipulation hasn't really shown to be combat applicable (at the very least it's not very effective). Just like Zoro Mihawk should be capable of dealing with his air manipulation.
How? No one even voted for him...
Mihawk Scale above Shanks ~ Kaido
Don’t care… you can’t say Mihawk FRA When no one has voted for him… also mihawk hasn’t done any damage to shanks but black beard has… Shanks ~ White Beard >> black beard > Mihawk
Some people here explain Mihawk Advantage, i used it for my Reason voting Mihawk
So why we Scale Mihawk above Shanks Then?… also mihawk hasn’t done any damage to shanks but black beard has… Shanks ~ White Beard >> black beard > Mihawk
Because shanks clashed with white beard and Mihawk is > shanks because he is the strongest swordsman…
You should made a CRT then.
No…
Then we should agree Mihawk > Shanks.
Maybe…
Mihawk FRA
Well Mihawks advantages are observation haki, and answers to regeneration and air manipulation.
