All things pink go into this pie (Pinkie Pie CRT)

[Peppersalt43]

Normally I just link these to the respective @Lightbuster30 posts but I'm planning on making a match which will involve people who will heavily scrutinize the profiles so let's just make this official

FiM!Pinkie Pie

Remove the "Gag" from Teleportation. She has actually used this in combat and was even still in her opponent's line of sight. Scan below


Pinkie Sense

Remove "Slight" from precognition, "limited" from clairvoyance, and add these two to the both profiles (FiM!Pinkie gets Clairvoyance, EQG!Pinkie gets Precog). Both iterations are capable of utilizing Pinkie Sense with the scan here and for reasoning on why EQG!Pinkie gets this, I'll just quote @Lightbuster30 on this.

If I'm lucky, this'll go smoothly

 

[MinatoSparkle]

I guess so. You could also argue it's Pinkie moving so fast Chrysalis can't see her but whatever.

 

[Jinsye]

It is still technically gag teleportation, she's just capable of using it offensively. But you can remove it if it's causing confusion.

Does EQG Pinkie Pie really have no other showings of Pinkie sense? I could've sworn she's demonstrated it at least once before. Regardless, I don't think that feat should be linked to Pinkie Sense at all, there's absolutely no proof beyond "well they work kinda similar".

Which doesn't even make sense, because Pinkie Sense is precognition via her body. However, it doesn't just give her an ability to know exactly everything in specific detail, since in Feeling Pinkie Keen she didn't even know what exactly a "doozy" was since she never experienced it before. Equestria Girls surely has never been experienced before, so she wouldn't know jack shit if it was actually Pinkie Sense.

So, with the lack of evidence pointing it to Pinkie Sense besides "well pinkie sense is a 6th sense" you can't really say it's the reason why EQG Pinkie knows all of that stuff.

Also an explanation given was just that it was the original Pinkie Pie so that's why she knew all of that. However, I don't think that's canon. It can be used as supporting evidence to prove intent though.

 

[Peppersalt43]

Does EQG Pinkie Pie really have no other showings of Pinkie sense? I could've sworn she's demonstrated it at least once before. Regardless, I don't think that feat should be linked to Pinkie Sense at all, there's absolutely no proof beyond "well they work kinda similar".

Which doesn't even make sense, because Pinkie Sense is precognition via her body. However, it doesn't just give her an ability to know exactly everything in specific detail, since in Feeling Pinkie Keen she didn't even know what exactly a "doozy" was since she never experienced it before. Equestria Girls surely has never been experienced before, so she wouldn't know jack shit if it was actually Pinkie Sense.

There is a quote she has that is kinda suspicious, that being

"You're from an alternate world and you're a pony princess there and the crown actually has a magical element embedded in it that helps power up other magical elements, and without it they don't work anymore, and you need them all to help protect your magical world, and if you don't get the crown tonight, you'll be stuck in this world and you won't be able to get back for, like, a really, really long time! [squee]"— To Twilight Sparkle, My Little Pony Equestria Girls

 

[Jinsye]

Yeah that's a gag thing that's not necessarily linking it to Pinkie Sense. There's no intrinsic link or that feat, especially because that feat is something that Pinkie Sense has never been shown once to do.

 

[Peppersalt43]

Yeah that's a gag thing that's not necessarily linking it to Pinkie Sense. There's no intrinsic link or that feat, especially because that feat is something that Pinkie Sense has never been shown once to do.

Wait, seriously? Didn't FiM!Pinkie also do this at the end of Equestria Girls? Somehow know about what had just been happening on the other side?

 

[Coolboy6]

I’m fine with the top part having Pinkie’s gag teleportation being used in combat however,

In the EQG bloopers, both versions of pinkie met up so they could very well have conversed with each other physically which is why I suggest a “possibly” rating for Clarvoyiance

 

[Jinsye]

Wait, seriously? Didn't FiM!Pinkie also do this at the end of Equestria Girls? Somehow know about what had just been happening on the other side?

Yeah, but that doesn't necessarily mean it's Pinkie Sense. There's still no proof of the two abilities being linked. You could give Pinkie possible clairvoyance based on that, though I would be a bit more apprehensive due to the already given explanation and it being a gag feat and whatnot.

 

[FinePoint]

Not confident enough to comment on EQ, but it does seem clear for Equestria Pinkie that it's combat-applicable for dodging.

 

[Peppersalt43]

Does EQG Pinkie Pie really have no other showings of Pinkie sense? I could've sworn she's demonstrated it at least once before. Regardless, I don't think that feat should be linked to Pinkie Sense at all, there's absolutely no proof beyond "well they work kinda similar".

Which doesn't even make sense, because Pinkie Sense is precognition via her body.

So uh, I found something else


The entire premise of the short is Pinkie figuring things out that she shouldn't be able to know via some feeling in her gut which is actually literal based on the ending. These are also her universe's things so it's not FiM!Pinkie telling her that

 

[Crabwhale]

I primarily agree with Jin here.

 

[Jinsye]

That could work, I wouldn't exactly correlate it to Pinkie Sense though.

 

[Peppersalt43]

That could work, I wouldn't exactly correlate it to Pinkie Sense though.

For precog reasoning?

Also you did say that

Pinkie Sense is precognition via her body.

Which this is also like that. Or at least pretty similar

The entire premise of the short is Pinkie figuring things out that she shouldn't be able to know via some feeling in her gut which is actually literal based on the ending.

 

[Peppersalt43]

sigh Bump

 

[DarkDragonMedeus]

I am neutral for now, there seems to be good points on both sides.

 

[Peppersalt43]

@Jinsye please come back...

 

[Peppersalt43]

Bump