• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Honkai: Star Rail Discussion Thread

Separate timelines ≠ different cosmology, prove the existence of 2 Imaginary Trees then
The Honkai in GGZ literally comes from a separate universe called the Honkai Universe. That's two whole universes. It also, has, ya know, different wills of Honkai.

kallen's timeline is a serperate timeline than hi3 so its another tree i guess
Didn't say that. I'm making a continuity claim. I don't think they're the same cosmology at all.
 
1775499709073.jpg

Same timeline fr unless we're jobbing APHO and Alien Space, they are still different leaf worlds tho
 
how can i agree with what ur saying and u still try to talk shit???? i literally said i was wrong bruh
I meant like I wanted to reiterate it's still different leaf worlds which meant different space-times instead of like "oh yeah they're the same space-times"
 
Didn't say that. I'm making a continuity claim. I don't think they're the same cosmology at all.
Well you're gonna need to prove that which should be impossible given the devs wanting to make a multiverse and Welt going from Hi3 -> HSR and Sparkle going from HSR -> Hi3.
Also the GGZ Collabs.

Also nothing here should be a disqualifier for 11D Tree just to clarify given it's not specifically stated the Tree in HSR is 4D or lower dimensional or whatever.
 
Well you're gonna need to prove that which should be impossible given the devs wanting to make a multiverse and Welt going from Hi3 -> HSR and Sparkle going from HSR -> Hi3.

Also nothing here should be a disqualifier for 11D Tree just to clarify given it's not specifically stated the Tree in HSR is 4D or lower dimensional or whatever.
hes talking about ggz and hi3/hsr being on seperate trees.
 
The Honkai in GGZ literally comes from a separate universe called the Honkai Universe. That's two whole universes. It also, has, ya know, different wills of Honkai.

Didn't say that. I'm making a continuity claim. I don't think they're the same cosmology at all.
How tf is GGZ splitting off HI3 because of what happened in St. Freya for them to have a completely different Imaginary Tree???
 
Well you're gonna need to prove that which should be impossible given the devs wanting to make a multiverse and Welt going from Hi3 -> HSR and Sparkle going from HSR -> Hi3.
This is for GGZ, not Hi3/HSR.

Also nothing here should be a disqualifier for 11D Tree just to clarify given it's not specifically stated the Tree in HSR is 4D or lower dimensional or whatever.
Tree in HSR refers to the physical world is the issue.
 
This is for GGZ, not Hi3/HSR.
Well they have numerous crossovers and also same most of the same events during Nagazora and pre-nagazora. Azure Waters is explicitly the same too btw. It was even originally designed to be a GGZ continuation.
I have my own grievances with it but there's not much that can be done lol.
Tree in HSR refers to the physical world is the issue.
Yeah it's not a disqualifier. The 11D tree forms the structure of the 4D universe with how the leaf worlds are positioned.
 
This is for GGZ, not Hi3/HSR.

Tree in HSR refers to the physical world is the issue.
It doesn't matter because High 1-C was explicitly for the Trunk of the Imaginary Tree
Can you explain to me how you reconcile the differences in the Honkai then?

Or is Cocoon now no longer scaling to the Tree?
I don't know how you got to this but Cocoon doesn't just scale to the Tree, it literally had feats of it transcending the Sea of Quanta (transcending all dimensions statement) and I am sure CoF scales to the Imaginary Space which you know is the origin of the universe (Imaginary Tree) heck it's as simple as the Aeons scaling to the trunk of the Tree that's the origin of infinity leaf worlds and CoF scaling to the Imaginary Space which is the origin of the trunk here
 
GGZ Honkai is difference to HI3 Honkai that much is true
HI3 have CoF as Honkai dictator while GGZ have WoH as Honkai dictator which both have entirely different goal and obviously being seperate entity
so yall gotta figure out smt like maybe GGZ Earth is in the same Branch as HI3 Earth while WoH come from different Branch or smt
 
GGZ Honkai is difference to HI3 Honkai that much is true
HI3 have CoF as Honkai dictator while GGZ have WoH as Honkai dictator which both have entirely different and obviously being seperate entity goal as well
so yall gotta figure out smt like maybe GGZ Earth is in the same Branch as HI3 Earth while WoH come from different Branch or smt
bruhhhhh WoH is just prometheus
💔
 
It doesn't matter because High 1-C was explicitly for the Trunk of the Imaginary Tree
No. It was accepted for the place that Otto calls the "membrane" of the Imaginary Tree. We know jack about the trunk.

I don't know how you got to this but Cocoon doesn't just scale to the Tree, it literally had feats of it transcending the Sea of Quanta (transcending all dimensions statement) and I am sure CoF scales to the Imaginary Space which you know is the origin of the universe (Imaginary Tree) heck it's as simple as the Aeons scaling to the trunk of the Tree that's the origin of infinity leaf worlds and CoF scaling to the Imaginary Space which is the origin of the trunk here
You don't get my point at all. Also, the Cocoon explicitly has no authority over SoQ. We're told this, and we're told it's the reason that Cocoon's influence could be washed away by the sea.
 
no..? its for the entire tree but only the higher dimensional part (the hi3 one) the hsr one is only 4D tho which is just the physial plane
The trunk of the tree ain't the physical plane, the branches (physical plane) literally originates from the trunk in the scan I gave earlier
 
GGZ Honkai is difference to HI3 Honkai that much is true
HI3 have CoF as Honkai dictator while GGZ have WoH as Honkai dictator which both have entirely different goal and obviously being seperate entity
so yall gotta figure out smt like maybe GGZ Earth is in the same Branch as HI3 Earth while WoH come from different Branch or smt
Probably differences in Prometheus. Maybe she got wiped out in GGZ and it lead to a more malicious Cocoon, who knows.
 
and lets say ggz is on a different tree than hi3/hsr. theres still genshin's universe which is on the tree and significant in size
genshin has 2 universes, the true universe and the dark universe (where the abyss originates)

This does not include the world created by the Primordial One
 
No. It was accepted for the place that Otto calls the "membrane" of the Imaginary Tree. We know jack about the trunk.

You don't get my point at all. Also, the Cocoon explicitly has no authority over SoQ. We're told this, and we're told it's the reason that Cocoon's influence could be washed away by the sea.
Oh my god, Nova you are not proposing High 1-C Herrscher of Rebirth > Cocoon of Finality just because HoR Seele has authority over SoQ.

It deadass doesn't matter because like the Cocoon transcends SoQ, literally.

Also wtf why would the "membrane" of the Imaginary Tree here be higher than like the literal trunk of the Tree (which is also called the highest plane in the Imaginary Tree to Aha)
 
The issue that it is impermissible if they are in the same Tree. Otherwise Cocoon isn't the sole authority or "the only Imaginary Singularity".
TBF they never even bring up the Tree in GGZ, it's just really iffy which is why I initially had issues with GGZ being in the cosmology (it makes inconsistencies like this) but they're clearly intended to be the part of the same cosmology. Best thing we can do is go off of statements where nothing about Imaginary Singularities is said in GGZ.
 
It deadass doesn't matter because like the Cocoon transcends SoQ, literally.
Yo, I didn't make this up. They literally say this. It's why the whole "The Sea washed away the Cocoon" thing came up a while ago.

Also wtf why would the "membrane" of the Imaginary Tree here be higher than like the literal trunk of the Tree
The membrane is Imaginary Space.

which is also called the highest plane in the Imaginary Tree to Aha
Aha... ascended the Trunk?
 
Deadass the true universe is just the leaf world and the dark universe is just the bubble world
I disagree with that, I've been saying this for a long time, but I'm too lazy to argue now, what's clear is that the HSR universe is also called the sea of stars, and the Genshin universe is also called the sea of stars.
The HSR universe is called the material world and the Genshin universe is also called the material world.
 
Yo, I didn't make this up. They literally say this. It's why the whole "The Sea washed away the Cocoon" thing came up a while ago.

The membrane is Imaginary Space.

Aha... ascended the Trunk?
I am pretty sure the entire Sea washing away the Cocoon thing was when it was still an alien civilization, but the moment it ascended as the Cocoon; It's not washed away anymore because it transcends the SoQ

Also wtf if the membrane is Imaginary Space then it's either Imaginary Space is actually the origin of Imaginary Tree because it's placed higher than the trunk here and that it's outside it or the membrane here is just the trunk basically

Aha was in the trunk, the trunk is the highest plane of Imaginary Tree not that Aha ascended it
 
Aha was in the trunk, the trunk is the highest plane of Imaginary Tree
Do you have a scan for this?

Also wtf if the membrane is Imaginary Space then it's either Imaginary Space is actually the origin of Imaginary Tree because it's placed higher than the trunk here and that it's outside it or the membrane here is just the trunk basically
The membrane is synonymous with IT itself. Because for Otto, Imaginary Space and Imaginary Tree are functionally the exact same.
 
bruhhhhh WoH is just prometheus
💔
GGZ WoH actively trying to destroy whatever GGZ have so even if its still Prometeus then it would be difference Prometeus which still seperate GGZ Honkai and HI3 Honkai from each other anyway due to different Entity controlling them which will lead to HI3 Prometeus having lower control over Honkai than GGZ Prometeus
Probably differences in Prometheus. Maybe she got wiped out in GGZ and it lead to a more malicious Cocoon, who knows.
If in GGZ Prometeus ever exist and have done the same thing then maybe
 
Back
Top