• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

The Sun God Nika vs The Six Paths Sage (Luffy vs Naruto).

Status
Not open for further replies.
Am I really seeing OP fans arguing that Luffy is gonna turn chakra into rubber even though he has never shown the ability to turn souls/mind into rubber. While in the same breath deny claims that chkara contains will and yet cannot EE haki cuz it’s not “proven”
You do not need to be able to transmute souls to transmute energy from souls

Naruto has never been able to existence erase willpower but yall wanna say he can erase Haki

So what are we talking about
Ryou haki has no innate resistance to EE. and Luffy can not rubberize TSO as they resist matter maniplation e.g Particle style which falls under Transmution
It does not need to have resistance to EE. The TSOs need to show to be able to erase something that phases.

There is no feat of Naruto's that has shown NPI to phasing
 
grinch-smile-grin.gif
is said if for a reason 🦧
"Haki is layered" means quite literally nothing in this context. Haki can have 5 gorillion layers and still not help you whatsoever against EE
Against powernull, yes it does... And then you need proof TSO can erase something like Haki
Good thing TSO having soul EE is not assumed but proven.
Good thing haki isn't composed of one's soul
 
I'm also seeing repeatedly that people keep talking about the TSOs erasing shit

The TSOs do not regularly erase. They turn things to dust. Only with Yin/Yang chakra do they do so.

We know Naruto is capable of doing so, but has Naruto ever willingly chose to erase people?
 
You do not need to be able to transmute souls to transmute energy from souls

Naruto has never been able to existence erase willpower but yall wanna say he can erase Haki

So what are we talking about

It does not need to have resistance to EE. The TSOs need to show to be able to erase something that phases.

There is no feat of Naruto's that has shown NPI to phasing
You calling it Will power doesn't make it all of a sudden a special thing.. It's spiritual energy if you argue that Chakra can't interact with Haki. Then it is vice versa, Haki wouldn't be able to do the same. Then take Haki and the One Piece verse out of the VS battle wiki this place is not for them you can do your battles Inverse only since no verse on the wiki has Haki.
 
Haki is not just energy as the ones in naruto, otherwise you're saying it's Existence Erasure can erase the power to feel others presence, the sensation of wanting to fight, and ones killing intent... that is literally what the 3 main Haki are composed of
And what is chakra made of? Mind/soul and guess what the mind does? It makes up emotion, will power, memories and killing intent. They all manifest through chakra, haki and chakra are similar and to not agree is to be disingenuous. You can’t point to anything in Hali’s composition that contradicts chkara none.
combining mental energy and physical energy turning that to Chakra... Haki is directly creating weapons from one's spiritual-type senses
This is wrong, chkara is metaphysical energy and always existed as such. That’s why ghost hags is called a chakra sprit cuz that’s what chakra is soul/mind. It was never created, you are conflating the chakra used for ninjutsu which incorporates physical energy as an enhancer rather than creator.

It’s like electricity, electricity is created from spinning a steam turbine (mental energy) and transformers are used to amplify them (physical energy) to be used in households.

This is literally chakra, it’s not created it is. The physical energy is used as an enhancer.
How is it erasing ones will when that has never happened..? Did Minato lose his will when getting affected? No? Then that's the specific Haki that gets turned into a weapon, you need proof it can erase senses/sensations
If you EE a substance that’s composed of will power and other factors, are you not EE will power? Just cuz a seasoned killer like Minato doesn’t get depressed because he lost a little bit of chakra (which he anyways constantly does via ninjutsu) doesn’t disqualify it
We know Naruto is capable of doing so, but has Naruto ever willingly chose to erase people?
Pretty sure both fighting in character and not bloodlust so true. 100%
Huh? Nard always fought characters that are resistant to TSO, so obviously you won’t see him EE stuff. Even when his is using them he has been careful not to let sakura or kakashi touch, prime example being that nard made a TSO platform for sasuke cuz he was resistant and not for kakashi and Shakura cuz they are not.

Let’s not discredit abilities
 
You do not need to be able to transmute souls to transmute energy from souls
You have to. Cuz you guys aren’t giving the same liberties to us for haki
Naruto has never been able to existence erase willpower but yall wanna say he can erase Haki
Chakra constructs? Like chakra is also will power materialized sword of nanaboku literally proves this
It does not need to have resistance to EE. The TSOs need to show to be able to erase something that phases.
Chakra is intangible and can phase through things (I.e souls) so yes it can EE
There is no feat of Naruto's that has shown NPI to phasing
Souls? Limbo?
 
hmmm...lets look at the accelerated development rq

yeah...he isn't gonna be able to tank for long...especially after luffy starts growing from clone spam

This is from the buso haki section of the haki page btw
  • Regeneration Negation (At least Mid, likely Mid-High; Haki users are capable of negating externally accelerated natural regeneration. like the regeneration granted by the Tori Tori no Mi: Model Phoenix)

No he really dosen't...they both start at equal values physically speaking and luffy is going to be growing at a noticably alarming rate...he does not have the durability to take repeated hits

even if he somehow did...haki has internal dura neg, yes naruto resists this but since haki also has resistance negation it would simply nullify this resistance and make naruto vulnerable
Haki has dura neg i know but haki have to bypass three thing before touching internal organs
Tso then chakra cloak then body of naruto
Can it bypass all of them
And naruto can use substution jutsu before luffy land the hit it ,cant he ?
Naruto just have to defend himself until luffy goes out g5 i still think he can do that
 
You calling it Will power doesn't make it all of a sudden a special thing.. It's spiritual energy if you argue that Chakra can't interact with Haki.
Sorry but are you trying to say that willpower and spiritual energy are the same thing?
Then it is vice versa, Haki wouldn't be able to do the same. Then take Haki and the One Piece verse out of the VS battle wiki this place is not for them you can do your battles Inverse only since no verse on the wiki has Haki.
Haki's effects don't really rely on a person having chakra so I don't see how chakra and haki being different (which is what OP supporters are arguing for anyway mind you) effects luffy's arguments here

If anything this helps luffy. In one piece the most common way to counter strong haki is with equally strong haki, if Naruto can't do that (which is what would be the case going on the premise that haki and chakra aren't the same) then luffy can use all his abilities without having to worry about the convention limitations he would normally deal with when fighting other haki users

Edit: ofc there are still conventional rules like if Naruto resists it's abilities naturally then he's fine but he doesn't (at least not things like resistance negatation and regen negation) which is the main issue
 
You calling it Will power doesn't make it all of a sudden a special thing.. It's spiritual energy if you argue that Chakra can't interact with Haki. Then it is vice versa, Haki wouldn't be able to do the same. Then take Haki and the One Piece verse out of the VS battle wiki this place is not for them you can do your battles Inverse only since no verse on the wiki has Haki.
Haki has dura neg i know but haki have to bypass three thing before touching internal organs
Tso then chakra cloak then body of naruto
Can it bypass all of them
And naruto can use substution jutsu before luffy land the hit it ,cant he ?
Naruto just have to defend himself until luffy goes out g5 i still think he can do that
doesn't even need that with his countless clones.

he can beat luffy before the timer.
 
You've been in this thread long enough to know that Luffy's statistic values are outdated. In fact, let me update them right now just for you.
going off what's on the profile.

he is 13c and has higher reactions.

40c with giant form.
 
Sorry but are you trying to say that willpower and spiritual energy are the same thing?

Haki's effects don't really rely on a person having chakra so I don't see how chakra and haki being different (which is what OP supporters are arguing for anyway mind you) effects luffy's arguments here

If anything this helps luffy if anything. In one piece the most common way to counter strong haki is with equally strong haki, if Naruto can't do that (which is what would be the case going on the premise that haki and chakra aren't the same) then Luffy can use all his abilities without having to worry about the conventional limitations he would normally deal with when fighting other haki users
Luffy can't interact with Chakra because it is made from Mental and physical energy.. The physical energy refers to cells and the mental energy includes emotions, experiences, etc, if you can't give me a reference for when Haki has directly interacted with these concepts combined then anything Naruto send his way can't be interacted, if you can't show me Luffy interacting with chakra specifically the one made from the Body and soul in Naruto all your argument becomes irrelevant.. Since you guys want to have your cake and eat it at the same time.
 
Then take Haki and the One Piece verse out of the VS battle wiki this place is not for them you can do your battles Inverse only since no verse on the wiki has Haki.
there are verses that do similar things, I've seen quite a few, Naruto definitely ain't one of them
It's spiritual energy if you argue that Chakra can't interact with Haki.
You do know it's never inverse ever been called "spiritual energy" we use that name for a different type of spirit.. With the energy coming from one's will,

For naruro it's Spiritual energy (精神エネルギー, seishin enerugī, English TV: Mental Energy)

Actually Law's ability straight up manipulates one's seishin
ローの"オペオペの実"の能力で精神と肉体が入れ替わってしまった!!

Law's “Ope Ope no Mi” ability has swapped their spirits with their bodies!
seishin relates more to one's overall soul while Haki is instead using specific spiritual sensations as weapons, they aren't legit just not the same thing
 
Yes.

No. Luffy is much faster. He will see Naruto's substitution several seconds ahead of time regardless.
Does luffy can see future continuously?
The speed difference does not make naruto unable to use his techniques naruto is quick thinker he should be able to escape the attack when we think about his senses.
İf i dont remember wrong that naruto character use substution jutsu against much faster enemy then them
 
And what is chakra made of? Mind/soul and guess what the mind does? It makes up emotion, will power, memories and killing intent. They all manifest through chakra, haki and chakra are similar and to not agree is to be disingenuous. You can’t point to anything in Hali’s composition that contradicts chkara none.
Theyre different. Just like senjutsu which is natural energy mixed in it. Why doesnt tso work on that again? So no, i guess tso doesnt work on everything.

This is wrong, chkara is metaphysical energy and always existed as such. That’s why ghost hags is called a chakra sprit cuz that’s what chakra is soul/mind. It was never created, you are conflating the chakra used for ninjutsu which incorporates physical energy as an enhancer rather than creator.
Show me a panel of haki users using ninjutsu. Last time i checked, when chakra users use up their chakra they die. When haki users use up their haki, theyre completly fine and still have stamina to fight. Theyre not the same.

And the rest u typed is a whole lotta nothing.
 
If you EE a substance that’s composed of will power and other factors, are you not EE will power? Just cuz a seasoned killer like Minato doesn’t get depressed because he lost a little bit of chakra (which he anyways constantly does via ninjutsu) doesn’t disqualify it
no you are not, one's spirit/soul creates ones willpower... Affecting the soul/spirit does not make you affect your will... Which is the same for Law
 
Huh? Nard always fought characters that are resistant to TSO, so obviously you won’t see him EE stuff. Even when his is using them he has been careful not to let sakura or kakashi touch, prime example being that nard made a TSO platform for sasuke cuz he was resistant and not for kakashi and Shakura cuz they are not.

Let’s not discredit abilities
Because they regularly turn things to dust it'll still hurt them regardless
You calling it Will power doesn't make it all of a sudden a special thing.. It's spiritual energy if you argue that Chakra can't interact with Haki. Then it is vice versa, Haki wouldn't be able to do the same. Then take Haki and the One Piece verse out of the VS battle wiki this place is not for them you can do your battles Inverse only since no verse on the wiki has Haki.
It is not spiritual energy in the sense of energy from your damn soul.
It is energy caused by willpower.

Naruto energy is not that. Naruto spiritual energy is not the energy from your willpower. It is the energy from their souls, consciousness, and experiences.

They are 2 completely different things.

You do not need to equalize an ability for it to be on a vs thread. If it doesn't equalize, then too bad.
 
Haki has dura neg i know but haki have to bypass three thing before touching internal organs
The energy is phasing through the exterior of something to hit it's interior

Unless these three things have NPI for intangibles, it's gets pass this no problem
Tso then chakra cloak then body of naruto
Can it bypass all of them
Can the TSO's and chakra cloaks interact with intangibles?
And naruto can use substution jutsu before luffy land the hit it ,cant he ?
His reactions are 28c. Luffy can consistently blitz 35c characters.
Naruto just have to defend himself until luffy goes out g5 i still think he can do that
Luffy just needs to stat stomp the clones and reach the real Naruto before he runs out of time.

I think since Naruto is gonna be drawing out the fight long enough for the time limit to be of importance, luffy will have enough time to grow and stat stomp him before the time limit is reached

At the end of the day tho Ig that's just differing opinions
 
bruh just changed luffy's speed on the profiles for this battle?

nah man this is something else, at this point.
Yeah, because we ****** up applying a revision.
It was already accepted on the wiki. We just added it to the profile.

If you have a problem with that
 
there are verses that do similar things, I've seen quite a few, Naruto definitely ain't one of them

You do know it's never inverse ever been called "spiritual energy" we use that name for a different type of spirit.. With the energy coming from one's will,

For naruro it's Spiritual energy (精神エネルギー, seishin enerugī, English TV: Mental Energy)

Actually Law's ability straight up manipulates one's seishin

seishin
relates more to one's overall soul while Haki is instead using specific spiritual sensations as weapons, they aren't legit just not the same thing
You just typed up a bunch of nonsense.. I repeat unless you can show me where anyone in one piece that has interacted with Chakra before, not just nature energy or other energy called chakra but specifically the chakra that comes from the Body and Mind, till then luffy or any other piece characters are not interacting with chakra.
 
You just typed up a bunch of nonsense.. I repeat unless you can show me where anyone in one piece that has interacted with Chakra before, not just nature energy or other energy called chakra but specifically the chakra that comes from the Body and Mind, till then luffy or any other piece characters are not interacting with chakra.
Cool, here's an alternative.
Until you showcase Naruto's truthseeking orb directly erasing something comprised from energy formed from willpower then you can not say that Naruto can erase Haki.
Capiche?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top