• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

The Sun God Nika vs The Six Paths Sage (Luffy vs Naruto).

Status
Not open for further replies.
In this case it kinda does, his npi comes from chakras innate nature of being able to just grab other intangible things and he’s covered in it
His NPI comes from the fact that he grabbed his soul.
It’s not really a move
He doesn't know how the technique works.
How is that the same thing?

Naruto’s soul doesn’t have npi it’s an intangible thing inside of him that Pain also having NPI but via different means can interact with.
Pain grabbed his soul by grabbing the cloak. If the cloak could stop stuff like that then his soul would've never been affected by that, but we can see that although Naruto can grab intangible things, he cannot stop intangible things from passing through him.
don’t focus on “durability” my point there was that Naruto’s cloak is through, at a cellular level it blocks things out, unlike skin where you can argue it can enter through the smallest of cracks, you can’t with Sage Mode or the KCM cloak bc they change how refined Naruto’s body is at blocking out things from entering his body.

phasing doesn’t mean it automatically goes through everything on some spacial manip stuff,
This is quite literally how quite literally all types of phasing works
Haki phasing through trees and skin doesn’t mean much against someone who uses the same kind of energy to block out attacks with said energy regularly shown to be able to touch or interact with other intangible spiritual energies.
All because you can interact with intangible things doesn't mean that you are passively able to stop intangible things.
We would mark that if that was the case, but unfortunately it isn't.
 
I think a lot of this boils down to Luffy having better options against Naruto’s move kit than vice versa in my opinion.

Biju bombs and probably even rasenshurikens are something Luffy can reflect in the same way he reflects Kaido’s or Saturn’s attacks.

Internal durability negation which we know to be something ninja’s are highly susceptible to. Luffy’s internal dura neg can deal critical damage to Naruto off of just one or a couple of blows.

Luffy has accelerated development as well as blunt force resistance to help deal with Naruto’s AP advantage and mitigate almost entirely. And Naruto’s Truth Seeking Orbs can be mitigated by Luffy’s advanced armament coated attacks which makes it so he doesn’t need to make physical contact with it.

Luffy also has greater speed and precognition compared to Naruto which allows him to deal with Naruto’s clones.

While I think this is a close matchup, I see Luffy’s arsenal of being able to mitigate Naruto’s advantages as well as having specific attacks well suited for taking Naruto down as being the overall strategy that will ultimately prevail in this fight, especially with Luffy’s other significant advantages such as his speed gap and future sight.
 
There are more then one type of Durability Negation.

Naruto is resistant ONLY to this type

Luffy utilizes these types
Naruto has
  • Energy based dura neg resistance that works up to a cellular level
  • and an aura that interacts with said energy innately due to being made of the same chakra.

Luffy makes his spiritual/life force energy project outside of his body and forces it to travel through solid objects (that have no such NPI against it)

It’s not just a matter of the resistance, it’s also bc of how chakra innately interacts with similar energies.
 
Ima IMa ignore the other comments and just leave them up for debate. Cuz we just gonna be going in circles. Observation haki is still far better with many more applications. There are many more precog battles on a higher lvl than there is in nardo due to only a limited few sharingan users cuz the whole clan dead and only that clan had good precog. Sage mode and stuff are just danger sensory and emotion sensory applications that observation haki already has.
Naruto already has a big AP advantage and can get stronger by absorbing more and more nature energy (didn’t take him long to come to that conclusion vs Sasuke either), or designate a clone to do it for him far away from the actual fight. I doubt the fight lasts hours when he has that advantage plus a hax move that can dismantle him at a microscopic level or erase him.

Kaido was one shotting luffy and knocked him out multiple times, Yet luffy got back up. The ap difference was also as big. Luffy has been fighting against those with higher ap advantage than himself. Luffy gets stronger as he fights. His power can spike from emotions also. 3× accelerative developments. Luffy has more chance of growing far stronger than naruto especially if the battle draws out. Luffy has evaded fatal blows for 13hrs against katakuri. His body can also instinctively move on its own to avoid fatal blows. Pretty sure haki emission can deflect/defend against tso. G5 turns it into rubber etc.

If theres no argument for naruto beating luffy in the 1st 30m-1hr then game over because luffy most likley be on his way to power spiking near nardos lvl.

How would naruto even manage against luffy's unpredictable fighting style? Naruto all he does is use his clones for trickery but it wont work on luffy due to coO as i said before. So what else does he have? Tso can be defended against. 🤷‍♂️ bijuu spam and that can be reflected.
 
Naruto FRA

Molecular lvl resistance to dura neg > Dura neg Internals

Organs contains molecules too bruh, this changes nothing
molecular DN res means you can stop attacks from bypassing durability Via molecular attack. Dura neg internal means a physical attack bypasses your organs no matter what armor you have. These are two completely different things.
luffy isn't reality warping attacks into your body?
regardless like godernet said above it's not getting past Naruto's body.

lets just agree to disagree cause we aren't changing each others mind.
🥀 😭 🥀
 
And Kurama chakra, and other Bijuu’s chakra, and elements like water and fire, and spacial portals.

Chakra just has the innate ability to interact with the intangible and has demonstrated that with similar energies like Haki
He doesn't know how the technique works.
He doesn’t need to understand its mechanics bc he can do it whenever and has shown the ability to do so
Pain grabbed his soul by grabbing the cloak. If the cloak could stop stuff like that then his soul would've never been affected by that, but we can see that although Naruto can grab intangible things, he cannot stop intangible things from passing through him.
That Pains ability is the ability to grab one’s soul in general, which exists in an esoteric non specific part of the body and is not at all the same thing as Luffy forcing energy into someone’s body.
This is quite literally how quite literally all types of phasing works
Phasing on wiki is turning matter briefly intangible.

Adv Buso isn’t turning something tangible suddenly intangible.

It’s making a normally intangible energy in the OP world flow through someone’s body.
All because you can interact with intangible things doesn't mean that you are passively able to stop intangible things.
That’s how chakra works, there’s no grab chakra jutsu,

chakra can touch chakra and KCM Nard is always covered in chakra.
We would mark that if that was the case, but unfortunately it isn't.
I mean that’s mechanically how it works.
 
molecular DN res means you can stop attacks from bypassing durability Via molecular attack. Dura neg internal means a physical attack bypasses your organs no matter what armor you have. These are two completely different things.
There's really no difference except the fact Naruto resist it on a deeper lvl than the Dura Neg can reach. Also, molecules are also physical so that point is really void
 
If Chakra and Haki are similar enough to be equalized, the TSO will nullify the Haki barrier upon contact, causing the invisible armour to vanish and expose Luffy to the orb's erasure effect

But even if Luffy can avoid touching the TSO, Naruto can still shape them into massive explosions that will overwhelm a Haki barrier and i'm pretty sure TSO has soul damage too
 
If Chakra and Haki are similar enough to be equalized, the TSO will nullify the Haki barrier upon contact, causing the invisible armour to vanish and expose Luffy to the orb's erasure effect
They aren't.
But even if Luffy can avoid touching the TSO, Naruto can still shape them into massive explosions that will overwhelm a Haki barrier and i'm pretty sure TSO has soul damage too
Luffy resists soul damage so this is a non-issue. Make relevant arguments please.
 
And Kurama chakra, and other Bijuu’s chakra, and elements like water and fire, and spacial portals.
not all types of intangibility are the same. all because you have elemental intan or immaterial intan doesn't mean you're good with phasing, this is why we mark them differently
Chakra just has the innate ability to interact with the intangible and has demonstrated that with similar energies like Haki
Some intan ≠ all intan
He doesn’t need to understand its mechanics bc he can do it whenever and has shown the ability to do so

That Pains ability is the ability to grab one’s soul in general, which exists in an esoteric non specific part of the body and is not at all the same thing as Luffy forcing energy into someone’s body.

Phasing on wiki is turning matter briefly intangible.

Adv Buso isn’t turning something tangible suddenly intangible.

It’s making a normally intangible energy in the OP world flow through someone’s body.
Buso is not normally intangible. This is why you can blast people with it but it takes effort to actually let it phase through people.
 
Even if they cannot be equalized Luffy still gets damaged by TSO. The TSO erasure is not just limited to chakra techniques only
it needs to show to work on a different power system before you come here and say it can erase that damn power system
the erasure has only been shown on chakra.
 
There's really no difference except the fact Naruto resist it on a deeper lvl than the Dura Neg can reach. Also, molecules are also physical so that point is really void
My brother, they are two entirely different kinds of duranegs.
 
We really need to stop with this chakra = Haki classification conversation.

They really shouldn’t be equalized there.
 
Kaido was one shotting luffy and knocked him out multiple times, Yet luffy got back up.
Every single time besides G5, when Kaido knocked Luffy down he was out and needed time or assstance before making a comeback that doesn’t say much

1st time gassing out post Kong Gatling; needed 10 minutes or so of stalling from Law, Kid, Killer, and Zoro

2nd time getting knocked out by Co3W Thunder Bagua: kid, Killer, and Law almost took out Big Mom and Zoro pulled out Asura.

3rd time: he literally almost drowned got food and a ride back to the fight while Yamato stalled.

4th time: literally died and revived by G5 while Kaido left.

This isn’t saying much tbh.
The ap difference was also as big. Luffy has been fighting against those with higher ap advantage than himself. Luffy gets stronger as he fights. His power can spike from emotions also. 3× accelerative developments. Luffy has more chance of growing far stronger than naruto especially if the battle draws out.
Luffy grows while a battle gets stronger assuming he isn’t knocked out or gassed first, Naruto always has the option to get stronger via more nature energy. One is a more readily accessible amp.
Luffy has evaded fatal blows for 13hrs against katakuri.
Katakuri is a tickle monster without his spear.
His body can also instinctively move on its own to avoid fatal blows. Pretty sure haki emission can deflect/defend against tso.
They can’t that’s very arguable if we’re being generous.
G5 turns it into rubber etc.
He’d be erased in constant why would turning it into a rubber ball of death change anything?
If theres no argument for naruto beating luffy in the 1st 30m-1hr then game over because luffy most likley be on his way to power spiking near nardos lvl.
And Naruto uses Boil Release or Nature energy to get even stronger.
How would naruto even manage against luffy's unpredictable fighting style? Naruto all he does is use his clones for trickery but it wont work on luffy due to coO as i said before.
Do we even know is Kenbun would be able to sus out the real Naruto given they all have minds a life force, and are pieces of the real Naruto (like a clone of Naruto having a soul to soul convo with Kurama when they first met Madara)
So what else does he have? Tso can be defended against. 🤷‍♂️ bijuu spam and that can be reflected.
None of that is getting reflected with a 2x to 6x gap that can grow with more amps
 
I'm not hurt by attacks that target the cells ≠ I'm immune to getting phased through and having my organs exploded

I can interact with elements ≠ I can interact with intangible energies that are dissimilar to anything in my verse

The sooner yall can understand these facts, the sooner we can move on and start to make valid arguments. Although there haven't been any for the past 14 pages from the Naruto side so I doubt they'll magically come up with some now.
 
Misrepresenting the argument man

Naruto in KCM can innately touch spiritual/life force energy because chakra is made of the same energy, it’s not a special technique or anything that’s just a property of chakra that chakra cloak users have.

And we know he can block out energy at a far more thorough level that anything Luffy has shown so there’s no arguing that the energy would somehow wiggle into his body through the energy cloak.

No matter how you spin it Haki is a spiritual/life force energy often tied to willpower

They’re so alike it’s honestly a shock that there’s so much push back for them being similar
 
Naruto in KCM can innately touch spiritual/life force energy because chakra is made of the same energy, it’s not a special technique or anything that’s just a property of chakra that chakra cloak users have.

No matter how you spin it Haki is a spiritual/life force energy often tied to willpower
Haki is not a spiritual/life force energy. I don't know who lied and told you that, but you need to find and sue them.
 
Could you explain why?
Chakra is the energy formed from 2 types of energies, from the cellular energy (your body) and your mental energy (mind/soul). The mental energy is from the mind's consciousness. It is literally energy from your metaphysical mind, which grows through studying, meditation, training and experience.

Haki is the energy that exists due to your Ambition, Drive, Vigor, Will.

These are not the same types of "spiritual energy". They need to stop being equalized.
 
My brother, they are two entirely different kinds of duranegs.
Are you telling me that someone resisting like heart poisoning on a molecular lvl would die to dura negating poison simply targetting the same heart on a surface/regular lvl?
 
No one needs to prove that TSO has to erase anything similar to Haki specifically at all. I just need to prove that they erase physical matter which TSO does. Since Haki and especially advanced armament is described as a physical or spiritual barrier it would still be subject to the TSO's erasure property once it makes physical contact, regardless of whether its "energy" is nullified or not
 
Last edited:
No one needs to prove that TSO has to erase anything similar Haki specifically at all. I just need to prove that they erase physical matter which TSO does. Since Haki and especially advanced armament is described as a physical or spiritual barrier it would still be subject to the TSO's erasure property once it makes physical contact, regardless of whether its "energy" is nullified or not
Haki is not physical matter.
 
Are you telling me that someone resisting like heart poisoning on a molecular lvl would die to dura negating poison simply targetting the same heart on a surface/regular lvl?
someone resisting a needle piercing them cannot resist somebody phasing into their body
 
Naruto in KCM can innately touch spiritual/life force energy because chakra is made of the same energy, it’s not a special technique or anything that’s just a property of chakra that chakra cloak users have.
You know that Advanced Haki Emission has shown the ability to flow through Haki coatings... right? Even if Haki and Chakra are equated, Naruto being coated in "Haki" doesn't mean it can block out Advanced Haki Emission. You have a fundamental misunderstanding in Haki and its applications so it's very bizarre to me how you're speaking as some sort of authority on the topic.
 
Chakra is the energy formed 2 types of energies, from the cellular energy (your body) and your mental energy (mind/soul). The mental energy is from the mind's consciousness. It is literally energy from your metaphysical mind, which grows through studying, meditation, training and experience.

Haki is the energy that exists due to your Ambition, Drive, Vigor, Will.

These are not the same types of "spiritual energy". They need to stop being equalized.
Furthermore, chakra is a physical thing existing in a person’s body. Humans have specific channels that chakra flows through and can impact their chakra levels if those specific parts of the body are damaged. Along with also amping their chakra via releasing specific pressure chakra gates in their body.

This is fundamentally distinct from Haki which doesn’t have a physical existence in a person’s body. A human in one piece doesn’t have any “Haki channels” and haki doesn’t flow through the body tangibly like chakra does. It’s entirely will based.
 
Chakra is the energy formed 2 types of energies, from the cellular energy (your body) and your mental energy (mind/soul). The mental energy is from the mind's consciousness. It is literally energy from your metaphysical mind, which grows through studying, meditation, training and experience.
Chakra exists in Edo Tensei who have no physical cells and in chakra spirits who are only soul and mind, not to mention soul and chakra are often colloquilsed with each other so that’s just not the case

That was the initial understanding of chakra by Shinobi who didn’t know enough about chakra’s origins
Haki is the energy that exists due to your Ambition, Drive, Vigor, Will.
All of those things exist in naruto

Resolve and anger and willpower fundamentally change your chakras nature like we see with mental amps and Kurama literally turning into a corrosive chakra beats of poison due to his anger

Yin chakra literally encompasses the consciousness and the soul, if anything Yin chakra is just a more all encompassing Haki I what it’s made of.
These are not the same types of "spiritual energy". They need to stop being equalized.
There’s literally no distinction outside of trying to make a distinction bc Haki is only “ambition or will” and Yin Chakra is mind/soul.
 
haki is similar enough to not work on TSB, it's so disingenous people are arguing here haki can ignore tsb lmao
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top