• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Honkai Cosmology Rework

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
5,380
Reaction score
2,830
I'll split this into two parts.

1. It was accepted here that the Tree should scale to the Sea of Quanta since it's apparently born from the "primordial chaos", but the same statement stated that the Tree became a huge, unrivaled Tree — Which means, undisputedly the Tree would have to be superior than the Sea of Quanta whatsoever, not to mention the entire "cosmos" thing that makes Imaginary Space (Path Space of the Aeons) as the trunk to be comparable to the Real Space or the physical plane of the Tree, this simply doesn't make sense for 2 parts (Irontomb is unable to affect the Path Space and it's only able to do so because it focused all its efforts to the Path of Erudition itself) — Aeons who reside in the Path Space as explained in Khaslana's section have to descend to the physical plane, where it's explained in the Simulated Universe and even Mare's statement that well, Aeons in the physical plane are simply projections of them from the Path Space which is why Irontomb's destruction of the cosmos, or the entire physical plane of the Tree is unable to affect other Aeons + Nanook still had other 6 Lord Ravagers to kill other Aeons for a reason.

2. We retain the entire Sea of Quanta (especially Ether Bathtub and Sugar Space dimension) to be lesser than when Otto himself became part of the Tree after transcending reality which is the former that I've mentioned and this is still accepted as a +1 dimensional difference, the Aeons are obviously superior than this.

Ether Bathtub is able to contain infinite quantity of 4-D Bubble Worlds, and that it cannot be described in a 3 or 4 dimensional framework in the Ether Bathtub section.

With this conclusion, the Ether Bathtub and the Sugar Space dimension that's within SoQ are 5-D, the physical plane of the Tree is 6-D through Otto and 7-D from Aeons given their superiority over the physical plane.

But I am not done yet, it was also accepted in the thread that the dimensions refer to the amount of them being infinite instead of their size, it's stated "can be" however Honkai also uses Hilbert Space and there's this particular Einstein statement that if transfinite cardinals are applied, Earth would be the lowest transfinite cardinal which is to say that it would simply be the equivalent of a Hilbert Space, whether the size is infinite or not, I don't think it should matter since it's still High 1-B as long as the amount of dimensions there is infinite and the Tree being "infinite" in relations to this would mean it's Aleph 1, this applies for the Aeons who would be High 1-B+.

More about this is explained right here

I'm writing my summary here, but basically after 4 pages of discussion, nothing had really changed that the thread I linked above especially for the Visual Novel scan alone to atleast be High 1-B, it used to go against SoQ being 11-D because it was used as the justification for their size being infinite in the blog but since it's accepted to refer as in the amount of dimensions instead, High 1-B is pretty much plausible here excluding the Einstein statement about transfinite cardinals and so on.

Staff Votes​

  • • Staff Approval:
  • • Neutral:
  • • Staff Disapproval: Vietthai96

Member Votes​

  • • Agree: Re5yh, Mbpoops, LoudestProcedure, Maniaunavailable (Disagree for High 1-B), KingOfDarknessBelow
  • • Neutral: Dragopentling, EddisherSound (Disagree for High 1-B)
  • • Disagree: Super_Nova, ExcelsIsBerny, SweetDao, Vesxpura, Yanina92, korea1234
 
Last edited:
i dont remember sugar space ever being part of SoQ when its literally part of imaginary space (durandal literally found one when exploring img space in ch 26ex and 28)
 
i dont remember sugar space ever being part of SoQ when its literally part of imaginary space (durandal literally found one when exploring img space in ch 26ex and 28)
I mean, the dimensions that Welt and Ryusuke fought on (thats what I was refering to) I'm sure it's within SoQ
 
i dont remember sugar space ever being part of SoQ when its literally part of imaginary space (durandal literally found one when exploring img space in ch 26ex and 28)
i dont think it is but welt and ryusuke did fight in the sugar space where ryusuke has his infamous r>f statement
 
0g5guayfdodz.jpg
 
Castorice again for nth time drag me into another Mihoyoverse thread, there are other GGZ, HSR, Genshin and even Z.Z.Z thread i have yet to evaluate

I will deal with this in about 100 years from now
Well tbf youre one of the only active thread mods besides like Godernet

(Praying for Prime FinePoint and ActuallySpaceMan’s return)
 
Castorice again for nth time drag me into another Mihoyoverse thread, there are other GGZ, HSR, Genshin and even Z.Z.Z thread i have yet to evaluate

I will deal with this in about 100 years from now
Hey how many votes does this crt need. Is it the standard 1 admin and 2 mods?

But I am not done yet, it was also accepted in the thread that the dimensions refer to the amount of them being infinite instead of their size, it's stated "can be" however Honkai also uses Hilbert Space and there's this particular Einstein statement that if transfinite cardinals are applied, Earth would be the lowest transfinite cardinal which is to say that it would simply be the equivalent of a Hilbert Space, whether the size is infinite or not, I don't think it should matter since it's still High 1-B as long as the amount of dimensions there is infinite and the Tree being "infinite" in relations to this would mean it's Aleph 1, this applies for the Aeons who would be High 1-B+.
Also considering this part looks like it was inspired by @Vietthai96, here’s additional argument from him

“ the second scan stated there are infinite lines perpendicular to each other. Dimensional axis is represented by Line, or Vector, so infinite lines are equivalent to infinite dimensional axes, and they are perpendicular which means different, infinite directions, not parallel”
 
Hey how many votes does this crt need. Is it the standard 1 admin and 2 mods?


Also considering this part looks like it was inspired by @Vietthai96, here’s additional argument from him

“ the second scan stated there are infinite lines perpendicular to each other. Dimensional axis is represented by Line, or Vector, so infinite lines are equivalent to infinite dimensional axes, and they are perpendicular which means different, infinite directions, not parallel”
i mean you could also put this on nova's post considering the grace idk how that would go since everyone is just shitposting but eh
 
i guess regarding "compact dimensions" nothing in this link (yes this is the entire scan from chapter 3 of the Durandal VN i can give you a download or browser link if required) states or hints at the dimensions being compact and the "analogous distance" between the "membranes" is not actual distance but a conceptual similarites within each bubble universe which cause them to share matter between eachother. when 2 membranes share enough similarities the membranes will begin to share matter, however, matter is easier to transfer from smaller to bigger membranes than the reverse (bigger to smaller) which causes the smaller membrane (bubble world) to disolve (cease to exist). basically the higher dimensional projection of reality can share similarities with the smaller thus causing it to basically take the matter from the smaller dimension and imprint it in the same spot as the higher dimension which is why the dimensions "overlap".
 
Yall mfs agreeing without specifying which proposal bro. Theres 2 routes. The first proposal is the Nether route is the second route is the Vietthai inspired route

I agree with the either proposal so far btw
 
Last edited:
Also please remove that Ether Bathtub isn't the Sea of Quanta, we already went through this

And can we not talking about 11D stuff, we went through it already
 
Castorice again for nth time drag me into another Mihoyoverse thread, there are other GGZ, HSR, Genshin and even Z.Z.Z thread i have yet to evaluate

I will deal with this in about 100 years from now
so to not make this 18 pages long, can u tag staff (again) pls?
 
Also please remove that Ether Bathtub isn't the Sea of Quanta, we already went through this

And can we not talking about 11D stuff, we went through it already
i can agree to this as it states in the durandal vn and other media that the bath is the SoQ. whoever made the cosmology page and said the Ether Anchor Point is the Ether bath and the SoQ is seperate from it pulled that shit out of seemingly nowhere
 
Also please remove that Ether Bathtub isn't the Sea of Quanta, we already went through this
I mean the Sea of Quanta would scale to the Ether Bathtub so it's practically the same thing, those on the Honkai Energy page directly scales from the Ether Bathtub iirc

Nothing much about SoQ other than them being 5-D since you know (as I don't believe it being 4-D), the rest pertains to the Imaginary Tree and stuff mainly
 
I mean the Sea of Quanta would scale to the Ether Bathtub so it's practically the same thing, those on the Honkai Energy page directly scales from the Ether Bathtub iirc

Nothing much about SoQ other than them being 5-D since you know (as I don't believe it being 4-D), the rest pertains to the Imaginary Tree and stuff mainly
i dont really believe in 5D SoQ either and think 11D is fine since its still the ether bath but if its 5D so be it
 
i dont really believe in 5D SoQ either and think 11D is fine since its still the ether bath but if its 5D so be it
I mean, hey, at bare minimum it should be 5-D since it encompasses infinite amount of Bubble Worlds but yeah I personally think it is still 11-D regardless of what has happened
 
Nothing much about SoQ other than them being 5-D since you know (as I don't believe it being 4-D), the rest pertains to the Imaginary Tree and stuff mainly
i dont really believe in 5D SoQ either and think 11D is fine since its still the ether bath but if its 5D so be it
Dudes, SoQ is still 11D, just not High 1-C, there are a lot of people who can't differentiate dimensions with tiering, insignificant, compactified dimension still dimension, just not get tiered. SoQ is still 11D, just only 5 dimensions are tierable which correspond to Low Complex Multiverse level in tiering system
 
Dudes, SoQ is still 11D, just not High 1-C, there are a lot of people who can't differentiate dimensions with tiering, insignificant, compactified dimension still dimension, just not get tiered. SoQ is still 11D, just only 5 dimensions are tierable which correspond to Low Complex Multiverse level in tiering system
how are the dimensions even compactified its never stated nor is it hinted at. in fact its even stated here that theres a selection made of which bubble universes inherit certain dimensions.
 
This thread is just the previous thread where 5-D was set but in disguise. Almost the same talking points.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top