• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Some Random One Piece CRT

Status
Not open for further replies.
Gear third is high 7-A+, 4 Gigatons, not baseline.
I thought G3 was baseline H7A+ (2,65GT if got the right numbers), but even then Luffy's first key clearly says that Boundman is 4x G2 outside of it's strongest attacks, why it changed to "far stronger than G3" instead of using the multiplier? And why the gap is big enough to upscale to 6C?
 
I thought G3 was baseline H7A+ (2,65GT if got the right numbers), but even then Luffy's first key clearly says that Boundman is 4x G2 outside of it's strongest attacks, why it changed to "far stronger than G3" instead of using the multiplier? And why the gap is big enough to upscale to 6C?
I’m pretty sure we already do because after round 2 gear 2nd would be Atleast high 7-A and x 4 would make gear 4th at least high 7-A+, but logically speaking we know the gear 4th Boundman that fought kaido (which is the one we’re using) > gear 4th Boundman round 2 > gear 3rd round 2(4 gigatons) logically speaking upscaling to 6-C would make complete sense since it’s way stronger than gear third, and there’s only a .3 gigaton gap between gear third and 6-C. It’s changed to far stronger due to upscaling. If baseline 6-C was like say 6 gigatons (an example) then gear 4th Boundman that fought kaido would just be “at least high 7-A+“ but its only .3 Gigatons off. That’s why after using the multiplier we upscale because we know gear 4th Boundman that fought kaido is above round 2 Boundman and round 2 gear third which is 4 gigatons. Upscaling here definitely makes sense. Also not to mention the gear 2nd from round 2 would also be unquantifiably above 1 gigaton because we know luffy got stronger, which means upscaling onto x4 multiplier would make even more sense.
 
Last edited:
I’m pretty sure we already do because after round 2 gear 2nd would be Atleast high 7-A and x 4 would make gear 4th at least high 7-A+, but logically speaking we know the gear 4th Boundman that fought kaido (which is the one we’re using) > gear 4th Boundman round 2 > gear 3rd round 2(4 gigatons) logically speaking upscaling to 6-C would make complete sense since it’s way stronger than gear third, and there’s only a .3 gigaton gap between gear third and 6-C. It’s changed to far stronger due to upscaling. If baseline 6-C was like say 6 gigatons (an example) then gear 4th Boundman that fought kaido would just be “at least high 7-A+“ but its only .3 Gigatons off. That’s why after using the multiplier we upscale because we know gear 4th Boundman that fought kaido is above round 2 Boundman and round 2 gear third which is 4 gigatons. Upscaling here definitely makes sense. Also not to mention the gear 2nd from round 2 would also be unquantifiably above 1 gigaton because we know luffy got stronger, which means upscaling onto x4 multiplier would make even more sense.
No, the key is for Round 2 Luffy, this is a up to WCI revision so anything that happened in Wano shouldn't be here, and even then why would the Boundman that fought Kaido be stronger? Luffy didn't get any upgrade iirc.

That aside, if the gap from G2 round 2 to it's previous versions is unquantifiable then you logically speaking can't assume it is a .3GT gap, we only know G2 is >1GT so G4 would also be >4G, there is absolutely nothing saying G4 needs to be way stronger than G3, much less to a point jumping to the next tier would be needed (this should only happen in one shots like Kaido vs Luffy, not any "x is stronger than y").

But what about Damage, Tempest and the others? I absolutely don't see the need for 6C at this point, but if everyone else sees then whatever.
 
I'm not a fan of upscaling in general and don't see the point for this.
 
Didn't the fight with Cracker basically show there's a big difference in power between Luffy's Gear Third and Boundman?

A Biscuit Soldier could block and deflect back Gear Third's strike while Boundman shattered it's shield with one strike and with the second completely destroyed the biscuit soldier despite clashing with a pretzel roll.

To me this shows a clear difference in power between the two gears and can justify upscaling.
 
Last edited:
Didn't the fight with Cracker basically show there's a big difference in power between Luffy's Gear Third and Boundman?

A Biscuit Soldier could block and deflect back Gear Third's strike while Boundman shattered it's shield with one strike and with the second completely destroyed the biscuit soldier despite clashing with a pretzel roll.

To me this shows a clear difference in power between the two gears and can justify upscaling.
This is much better.

Anyway, i will agre with 6C but it's not 100% because of this, G2 needs a mere .075 increase to G4's multiplier to get 4.3GTs

Even then, i think putting it as Likely 6C wouldn't hurt anyone.
 
This is much better.

Anyway, i will agre with 6C but it's not 100% because of this, G2 needs a mere .075 increase to G4's multiplier to get 4.3GTs

Even then, i think putting it as Likely 6C wouldn't hurt anyone.
I think likely 6-C is still a lowball, we clearly know it’s way stronger from how emin mentioned, 6-C should be perfectly fine to list, instead of just a likely. Also what did you mean with .075 increase to gear 4ths multiplier? We know luffy got stronger from round 1 to round 2, which is why gear third matched katakuris awakening. That’s literally how upscaling works, and the minimum requiring for upscaling is x 1.1, which this literally falls under because 4.3 < 4.4 lmao.
 
Last edited:
Just a straight up 6-C is fine imo, the difference to justify this upscaling is less than 1.1 times.

I'm not quite sure what was being discussed about gear second so if someone could explain that to me it would be great.
 
Just a straight up 6-C is fine imo, the difference to justify this upscaling is less than 1.1 times.

I'm not quite sure what was being discussed about gear second so if someone could explain that to me it would be great.
Basically dragnoir said that we should use the multiplier on gear 2nd for round 2, which I think is pointless because either way we know luffy got stronger through round 2
 
If i am not mistaken, G2 is baseline H7A (1GT) and it would need to be 1.075GT (here is the .075 increase) for a G4's 4x get 6C (4.3GT)
 
If i am not mistaken, G2 is baseline H7A (1GT) and it would need to be 1.075GT (here is the .075 increase) for a G4's 4x get 6C (4.3GT)
G2 round 1 is 1 GT, round 2 is unquantifiably higher. This really doesn’t prove anything because gear 4th would upscale regardless, since luffy got stronger.
 
If i am not mistaken, G2 is baseline H7A (1GT) and it would need to be 1.075GT (here is the .075 increase) for a G4's 4x get 6C (4.3GT)
We don't know how strong Gear Second during round 2 since he didn't use it so we can't say he's baseline H7A. But we do know he got stronger so very likely his gear second is stronger as well.
 
I still think Trebol should scale from his Durability. He practically KO'd himself before his wounds could. Also gotta remember Robin was scared of him and they used a method to separate Sugar's only protector despite Robin having High 7-A AP, and could just one-shot him going off the edits.
  • Robin made sure she couldn't interact with Trebol and ran for it, using a clone as a decoy, despite this being ridiculous if you consider the idea Trebol would be <1/100th as strong as her.

And while not AP, he did keep Luffy in check while he was in base.'

Edit: Oh wait, he also hurt Law at the start of Chapter 780 btw. Used his Sticky Launcher and Law was flat on the ground, in pain.

(I'm not sure if this is just me misinterpreting the translation, but Viola refers to Trebol and Doflamingo as "the worst of the family" before abruptly stating that their side "lost a lot of strength as well", referring to Law's apparent demise)
 
Last edited:
I still think Trebol should scale from his Durability. He practically KO'd himself before his wounds could. Also gotta remember Robin was scared of him and they used a method to separate Sugar's only protector despite Robin having High 7-A AP, and could just one-shot him going off the edits.
  • Robin made sure she couldn't interact with Trebol and ran for it, using a clone as a decoy, despite this being ridiculous if you consider the idea Trebol would be <1/100th as strong as her.

And while not AP, he did keep Luffy in check while he was in base.'

Edit: Oh wait, he also hurt Law at the start of Chapter 780 btw. Used his Sticky Launcher and Law was flat on the ground, in pain.
Makes a better case for usopp not scaling to trebol, nice case. Then it’s perfectly fine for him to scale to city level off of Caesar. Anyways, do you see anything else wrong? Or is it fine to you (still think usopp should scale to trebol though)
 
Last edited:
Makes a better case for usopp not scaling to trebol, nice case. Then it’s perfectly fine for him to scale to city level off of Caesar. Anyways, do you see anything else wrong? Or is it fine to you
Sabo AP (which his Dura can scale to since obviously he has purely physical feats) > Diamante's tool Durability ~ Kyros AP.

Burgess could hurt Sabo, and clashed with him (despite coming up short and being overpowered during their fight, which lasted only 10 or so minutes going based off the events), so Burgess < Sabo, but still within the same tiering.

Fujitora simply scales above Sabo as he was confirmed to be holding back against him for obvious reasons.

---

Crocodile is interesting, because in my opinion, I do not think Luffy's power growth from East Blue to Marineford was particularly massive (ESPECIALLY from EB->Water7), and that would support my idea that Crocodile didn't get "stronger" in prison, just serious and got his act together.
  • I'd honestly go as far to say that Crocodile since Alabasta has always been only like 2 steps below the likes of Doffy/Akainu/Jozu. But considering how 2 of those made him into a literal joke and the 3rd is scaling above those other 2, it's clear Crocodile shouldn't be scaling to them.
Doflamingo caught Crocodile's attack and didn't budge. Fight went off-panel, and we KNOW Doflamingo had no intentions of killing Crocodile at all, which was established 2 times before Crocodile actually attacked him. He saved Crocodile from Jozu, then cut Croc's head off without Haki, knowing his Logia ability would protect him. Doflamingo wanted to recruit Crocodile as a potential Executive in his family, and thus didn't try to kill him.

Jozu punched Crocodile hard. Croc was still seriously damaged as he had blood coming out of every orifice, but he isn't MASSIVELY inferior to Jozu, since he was mostly fine and the injuries weren't grievous.

Croc's attack on Akainu didn't do damage, just stalled him. We don't see how he performs against Akainu, and we know he has the entirety of the WB pirated helping him at this point.

For AP, Croc has no support outside of Impel Down feats. He never got to attack Jozu, and his attacks were ineffective against Doffy (who was holding back by a lot) and Akainu. No AP scaling is sensible.

For Durability, Croc's only logical feat is from taking a punch from Jozu, but considering the circumstances, I would only give him a "likely higher" dura scaling for a) taking no visible damage from Gear 2nd Luffy's kick, and b) Withstood the impact of Jozu's Brilliant Punk despite being injured.

At the end of the day, Crocodile > Impel Down Guards for AP. > Gear 2nd Luffy but < Jozu for Durability.
 
I still think Trebol should scale from his Durability. He practically KO'd himself before his wounds could. Also gotta remember Robin was scared of him and they used a method to separate Sugar's only protector despite Robin having High 7-A AP, and could just one-shot him going off the edits.
  • Robin made sure she couldn't interact with Trebol and ran for it, using a clone as a decoy, despite this being ridiculous if you consider the idea Trebol would be <1/100th as strong as her.

And while not AP, he did keep Luffy in check while he was in base.'

Edit: Oh wait, he also hurt Law at the start of Chapter 780 btw. Used his Sticky Launcher and Law was flat on the ground, in pain.

(I'm not sure if this is just me misinterpreting the translation, but Viola refers to Trebol and Doflamingo as "the worst of the family" before abruptly stating that their side "lost a lot of strength as well", referring to Law's apparent demise)
Well wait, wasn’t sticky launcher off screen? Plus we have to take into account that law was already messed up by Doflamingo so even if he did that, wouldn’t that not give Trebol a valid way to scale?
 
And what's the reason for Caesar's AP to be city level?
Just hypothetically, what would things look like we scaled Usopp's durability to be "At least Town level" for being superior to his Pre-Timeskip self?
 
Just hypothetically, what would things look like we scaled Usopp's durability to be "At least Town level" for being superior to his Pre-Timeskip self?
Values would arguably be lower than where we currently have the profiles even, which I don't think anyone would agree with, since majority of us believe usopp should scale to trebol
 
Still agree with Usopp's durability scaling to Trebol's AP; we see multiple explosions in the background of their fight and none of them bare resemblance to Usopp's pop green explosions. We know these explosions hit Usopp as when we see him smoke is still coming off his body, Trebol felt it was necessary to pin down usopp with his slime as well.
 
Still agree with Usopp's durability scaling to Trebol's AP; we see multiple explosions in the background of their fight and none of them bare resemblance to Usopp's pop green explosions. We know these explosions hit Usopp as when we see him smoke is still coming off his body, Trebol felt it was necessary to pin down usopp with his slime as well.
I think this makes sense.
 
Do any of those explosions look like they can be calced?

Values would arguably be lower than where we currently have the profiles even, which I don't think anyone would agree with, since majority of us believe usopp should scale to trebol

Wouldn't most of the character just revert back to their previous scaling then?
 
Do any of those explosions look like they can be calced?



Wouldn't most of the character just revert back to their previous scaling then?
Bro, I don't understand what's the need to calc those explosions WHEN TREBOL ALREADY HAS SCALING? I don't get why we would need to calc those, just for us to get TIER 8 RESULTS. This is what I mean damage when I say it's lowball from your part. We don't need to calc literal tier 8 explosions, when trebol's ap is far above that and he scales to 7-B ALREADY.

Yeah, exactly, but we think usopp should scale to trebol via his durability.
 
Last edited:
Bro, I don't understand what's the need to calc those explosions WHEN TREBOL ALREADY HAS SCALING? I don't get why we would need to calc those, just for us to get TIER 8 RESULTS. This is what I mean damage when I say it's lowball from your part. We don't need to calc literal tier 8 explosions, when trebol's ap is far above that and he scales to 7-B ALREADY.

Yeah, exactly, but we think usopp should scale to trebol via his durability.

When the scaling is so loose and unreliable, then I tend to default back to actually calcing a character's feats. Who has Trebol harmed with those explosions? Why exactly are those particular explosions 7-B? Is there some kind of law that makes any attack from Trebol, whether he be flicking a fly out of the air or making an explosion (regardless of the explosion's actual size) to be City level by default?

Maybe the alternative, that Usopp isn't that durable, isn't farfetched?

Can anyone actually see why I find these roundabout methods so confusing and unreliable? We have to rely on assuming that Usopp knows the potency of the explosions he can withstand, to figure out how durable he is, and he assesses that Hody Jones has equal potency to those explosions? Usopp can just estimate Hody Jones' power level based on him hurting fodder? Usopp being scared of Hody means Hody Jones' AP = Trebol's explosions (that hadn't happened to Usopp yet).

I know you don't agree with me, but do you see where I'm coming from here?

EDIT: Just a question; has Usopp ever deliberately not dodged an attack when he could dodge it?
 
Last edited:
When the scaling is so loose and unreliable, then I tend to default back to actually calcing a character's feats. Who has Trebol harmed with those explosions? Why exactly are those particular explosions 7-B? Is there some kind of law that makes any attack from Trebol, whether he be flicking a fly out of the air or making an explosion (regardless of the explosion's actual size) to be City level by default?

Maybe the alternative, that Usopp isn't that durable, isn't farfetched?
That's literally how attack potency works, it's his attacks coming from him. No, that's not the alternative, why are you suggesting that those explosions are somehow weaker than trebol's attacks? It's literally part of his attack potency value which is 7-B. Usopp has tanked them and endured multiple of them, therefore should scale to it. How is the scaling loose and unreliable? It's far more reliable than what we currently have.
 
When the scaling is so loose and unreliable, then I tend to default back to actually calcing a character's feats. Who has Trebol harmed with those explosions? Why exactly are those particular explosions 7-B? Is there some kind of law that makes any attack from Trebol, whether he be flicking a fly out of the air or making an explosion (regardless of the explosion's actual size) to be City level by default?

Maybe the alternative, that Usopp isn't that durable, isn't farfetched?

Can anyone actually see why I find these roundabout methods so confusing and unreliable? We have to rely on assuming that Usopp knows the potency of the explosions he can withstand, to figure out how durable he is, and he assesses that Hody Jones has equal potency to those explosions? Usopp can just estimate Hody Jones' power level based on him hurting fodder? Usopp being scared of Hody means Hody Jones' AP = Trebol's explosions (that hadn't happened to Usopp yet).

I know you don't agree with me, but do you see where I'm coming from here?

EDIT: Just a question; has Usopp ever deliberately not dodged an attack when he could dodge it?
It doesn’t seem like usopp just gets scared of any opponent casually, and that he was scared off the strength and power hody showed as a whole. He trained for two years as well, which also shows that he should know what he should be capable of, why else did he just blatantly go back to stand up to Trebol. He’s able to do that to Trebol, but not hody. Him then taking multiple explosions, shows that multiple were needed to take him out, and he took multiple of them before he was glued shut by Trebol. Also Trebols explosions don’t have to be = to hody, they can just be relative but we know they both have a valid case of scaling to 7-B, saying they’re equal doesn’t mean anything, like I said they can be relative as well.
 
Can anyone actually see why I find these roundabout methods so confusing and unreliable? We have to rely on assuming that Usopp knows the potency of the explosions he can withstand, to figure out how durable he is, and he assesses that Hody Jones has equal potency to those explosions? Usopp can just estimate Hody Jones' power level based on him hurting fodder? Usopp being scared of Hody means Hody Jones' AP = Trebol's explosions (that hadn't happened to Usopp yet).
We can use this logic for 99% of the wiki and shut down everyone who doesn't have a way to sense power to say "he's stronger than him".
Usopp took explosions from one man but was scared of the strength and the attacks and the other man. That other man > explosion man
EDIT: Just a question; has Usopp ever deliberately not dodged an attack when he could dodge it?
When Chew socked him.
When he fought Luffy and got punched in the face.
When he got his ass beat by Enel.
When he was getting manhandled by Franky.
When he was fighting Mr. 4 and his partner.

When he fought Perona. Again.
When he got bullied by a bear.
When Kuma reflected his own attack back at him.

Your point is?
 
We can use this logic for 99% of the wiki and shut down everyone who doesn't have a way to sense power to say "he's stronger than him".
Usopp took explosions from one man but was scared of the strength and the attacks and the other man. That other man > explosion man

When Chew socked him.
When he fought Luffy and got punched in the face.
When he got his ass beat by Enel.
When he was getting manhandled by Franky.
When he was fighting Mr. 4 and his partner.

When he fought Perona. Again.
When he got bullied by a bear.
When Kuma reflected his own attack back at him.

Your point is?
Agreed.
 
imho, Trebol should scale from hurting Law (Robin too if she happens to keep High 7-A scaling for x reasons).

But Usopp should not be scaling to Trebol from what we actually see go down. He got hurt by rubble, not even from the brunt of Trebol's attack hitting him, and was soundly defeated (rather quickly if we ignore the Kyros flashback chapter/s), not to mention he didn't even do anything to him.

Anyone who disagrees, provide ACTUAL EVIDENCE to the contrary....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top